Texas Justices Weighing Free Speech Rights With 'Pole Tax'

AUSTIN, Texas — Oral arguments are slated for March 25 in a Texas Supreme Court case that may decide whether the government can tax content protected by the 1st Amendment.

The issue at hand is the legality of charging a $5-per-person “pole tax” to customers of Texas’ 115 strip clubs and other adult entertainment venues, which Texas justices have decided to weigh.

The state, which has collected more than $12 million in fees that have been held in escrow pending the final outcome of the case, lost a round at court when a judge struck down the pole tax in March 2008. The state lost again in June when a state court of appeals decided the tax’s fate.

The law, passed in the 2007 legislative session, originally directed revenues collected from the fee toward sexual abuse and violence treatment and prevention programs, but it has been mired in legal challenges since it took effect.

Last year, an alternative measure was introduced that would include a 10 percent tax to those sexually oriented businesses that charge an admission fee. But the measure was postponed nine months ago.

That bill was hammered out with the help of members of the Texas Entertainment Association, an industry trade association for Texas strip-club owners.

Texas litigator David A. Furlow, who has represented businesses in numerous cases involving 1st Amendment protections, told the Houston Chronicle that the central issue of the pole tax is whether the government can levy a tax on speech.

“When you say certain types of messages and certain types of entertainment can be taxed, you begin down a slippery slope that can allow the government to destroy a form of business by taxing it out of existence,” he said.

To defend the law, the government has been forced to argue that strip clubs lead to greater violence against women, a claim for which there is no evidence, Furlow said.

The Utah Supreme Court upheld a similar law last year, ruling that taxing strip club patrons did not have the effect of restricting expression and served “an important state interest.”

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Holiday Now Shipping Rock Candy's 'Sweet Stash' Collection

Holiday Products is now shipping Rock Candy's Sweet Stash rechargeable mini vibe collection.

Orion Introduces New Dual Stimulator From 'Javida'

Orion Wholesale has debuted the new 2-Function Vibrator With Moving Clitoris Tickler from its Javida line.

Eye of Love's Jacqui Rubinoff Brings Pheromone Education to SoCal's 'Sex on the Beach'

Eye of Love Vice President Jacqui Rubinoff spoke earlier this month at the third annual Sex on the Beach event in Venice, California.

Mr. Hankey's Toys Debuts 4 New Dildos

Mr. Hankey's Toys has released its new Cyberpunk dildo, and is now also offering ErotixxxToys' Big Head, End Zone and Sea Monster dildos from its Bold collection.

Cherie DeVille Lambasts Laila Mickelwait's Anti-Pornhub Book in New Op-Ed

2023 XBIZ Performer of the Year Cherie DeVille has penned a new opinion piece for The Daily Beast, about a new book by religiously motivated anti-Pornhub crusader Laila Mickelwait.

Coquette Debuts 2024 'Darque' Collection

Coquette Lingerie has debuted its 2024 Darque collection, featuring 20 new styles with a mix of “classic wet look” and fresh materials.

Orion Debuts 3 New Men's Outfits From Black Level

Orion Wholesale has introduced three new outfits from its men's apparel line Black Level.

Federal Prosecutors Seek 20-Year Sentences for Remaining Backpage Defendants

Federal prosecutors asked on Monday that the three remaining defendants in the protracted Backpage.com case in Arizona be sentenced to 20 years in prison each.

Doc Johnson Unveils 'Main Squeeze,' 'Signature' Strokers Modeled From 16 Top Performers

Doc Johnson has released 32 new Main Squeeze and Signature Strokers, molded from 16 noted adult performers.

SexToyDistributing.com Shipping New Additions to 'Bang!' Line

SexToyDistributing.com is now shipping six new additions to the Bang! line.

Show More