Vivid: AHF Shouldn't Be Able to Intervene in Measure B Appeal

LOS ANGELES — Vivid Entertainment attorneys filed court papers yesterday with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals asking the court to dismiss the AIDS Healthcare Foundation as intervenors in the studio's appeal to effectively stop enforcement of Measure B.

Vivid, along with co-plaintiffs Kayden Kross and Logan Pierce, filed an appeal with the 9th Circuit last month after they were denied a preliminary injunction over Measure B by U.S. District Court Judge Dean Pregerson. The voter-approved measure requires the use of condoms in the production of adult movies in Los Angeles County.

Last week, Los Angeles County's appointed counsel told the clerk for the 9th Circuit that the county has chosen not to file an answering brief in the appeal over the preliminary injunction.

With the county not answering the appeal, AHF, the main supporter of the porn-condom measure and an intervenor in the lower court case, again seeks intervenor status — a status that Vivid is, again, battling against.

Vivid counsel argue in their reply brief to the 9th Circuit that the AHF must satisfy Article III of the U.S. Constitution, a statute that allows only an entity or individual who has suffered injury itself or himself to bring a case or appeal in federal court. They also argue that one party's satisfaction of Article III does not satisfy the requirement for all other participants and that the AHF lacks any protectable interest in the appeal.

Vivid attorneys said in their reply that the AHF can be only seen as a friend of the court, at best, in its appeal over the preliminary injunction.

At the lower court this past summer, Vivid was denied a motion to knock AHF off the case by Pregerson, who said that he disagreed with studio's claim that the U.S. Supreme Court in Hollingsworth vs. Perry requires intervenors to show they have standing independent of the actual defendants in case, Los Angeles County.

Pregerson earlier this year granted AHF's motion to intervene based on the 9th Circuit case Hollingsworth vs. Perry. That ruling held that opponents of gay marriage behind California's 2008 Proposition 8 effort had the constitutional authority, or standing, to defend the law in federal courts after the state refused to appeal its loss at trial years earlier.

But the U.S. Supreme Court in June overturned the 9th Circuit’s Hollingsworth decision, and Vivid asked Pregerson to disqualify the AHF as intervenors.

But Pregerson denied Vivid’s motion, ruling that the U.S. Supreme Court decision “implicitly approved of the framework currently at issue” because it left the district court’s decision intact in the Hollingsworth ruling.

“At the district court level, intervention by initiative proponents is proper when the government is enforcing the initiative but refuses to defend it, regardless of whether the intervenors have standing independent of the government defendants,” Pregerson wrote in his decision that favored the AHF.

But at the federal appellate level over the questions involving the preliminary injunction, Vivid attorneys wrote that the AHF must butt out. It their latest brief, Vivid counsel said that the only point at issue on its current motion with the 9th Circuit is the AHF’s claim to full party status on appeal.

"AHF’s insistence that they are 'needed' in this case is incorrect," Vivid attorneys wrote. "This court is more than capable of resolving the issues appellants raise notwithstanding the county’s election of the option to not file an answering brief.

"AHF has no interest in this litigation sufficient to satisfy either Article III standing or intervention ... ," Vivid attorneys wrote. "[The] intervenors accordingly should be dismissed as parties to this case."

View reply brief

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Angela White Stars in New Interactive Scene From Brazzers

Multi-XMAs winner Angela White stars with reigning and two-time XMAs Europas Male Performer of the Year Christian Clay in a new interactive release from Brazzers, titled “Taking Angela Back To Your Place.”

Marvin Love Directs 'Rich and Horny Weirdos' for Brazzers

Brazzers has released a new scene directed by Marvin Love, titled “Rich and Horny Weirdos.”

Julia James, Sage Hunter Topline 'Lesbian Sister In-Laws' Sequel

Julia James and Sage Hunter headline the latest release from Girlfriends Films, titled “Lesbian Sister In-Laws 2.”

Jade Greene Fronts Latest From TeamSkeet

Jade Greene stars with Nicky Rebel in the latest release from TeamSkeet.

Bree Mills Wraps Production on Pure Taboo Thriller 'Let Me In Too'

Adult Time has announced that production has wrapped on the Bree Mills thriller sequel "Let Me In Too."

Emma Rosie, Rebel Rhyder Topline Latest Volume of 'Hookup Hotshot: E-Girls'

Emma Rosie and Rebel Rhyder headline Brian Gozzling’s “Hookup Hotshot: E-Girls 28” from Evil Angel.

Agatha Vega Fronts Latest From Ricky's Room

Reigning XMA Europas Female Performer of the Year Agatha Vega stars in the latest release from Ricky's Room, titled "Agatha Habla Sucio."

Taylor Vixxen Makes Her MILFY Debut

Taylor Vixxen has made her debut for Vixen Media Group (VMG) studio imprint MILFY, alongside Dan Damage.

Catherine Knight Makes Her Vixen Debut

Catherine Knight has made her Vixen debut alongside Dan Damage.

Andi Avalon Headlines 'Slutty Nurses 3' From Reality Junkies

Andi Avalon toplines the third volume of "Slutty Nurses" from Mile High Media studio imprint Reality Junkies.

Show More