Randazza: Reversal of Fortune in Taiwan for Porn Producers

LAS VEGAS — A Taiwanese court decision last week reverses the fortunes of porn producers seeking to enforce their rights in the Chinese republic. 

In 1999, a Taiwanese criminal decision determined that pornographic works were not subject to copyright protection under Article 3 of the Taiwanese copyright Act. The court determined that given the fact that protecting the works was contrary to public policy, they were not subject to copyright protection in Taiwanese courts. This led anti-copyright voices worldwide to celebrate an apparent victory – that porn was not copyrightable in at least one country. 

After this decision, commentators noted the tension between the Taiwanese Intellectual Property Office (TIPO) and the Taiwanese Courts. In Case 250 of 1999, the Taiwanese Supreme Court held that since pornography is against social order and the public interest, it is not subject to copyright protection. This was affirmed in Taiwan High Court appeal No. 94 of 2005.

However, TIPO maintained the position that as long as the works are original, they are copyrightable – even if deemed to be legally obscene.This is the position that U.S. courts have taken as well – that obscenity and copyrightability are not intertwined. 

The disconnect between TIPO and the Taiwanese courts was likely due to the fact that TIPO is in a superior position to evaluate international agreements, and the Taiwanese Supreme Court position is contrary to international accords. The Berne Convention requires all member states to protect copyrighted works from all other member states.

While Taiwan is not a member of the Berne Convention, it is a member of the WTO. In order to join the WTO, Taiwan had to sign on to the TRIPs Agreement – which incorporates the first 21 Articles of the Berne Convention. Back-doored into the Berne Agreement’s provisions on copyright, Taiwan was in a quandary – as its high court decisions were placing it in violation of the TRIPs Agreement. 

However, last week, the Taiwanese Supreme Court appears to have accepted TIPO’s view and agreed that copyright protection was available to pornographic works. Despite this, given the language from news reports about the ruling (at the time of this article, the ruling itself was unavailable), it appears that the Taiwanese high court reluctantly recognized the copyrightability of the pornographic content of the subject Japanese film due to the fact that international treaties (namely TRIPs) created such an obligation -- if they are copyrighted in their country of origin.

Interestingly enough, it appears that the Taiwanese court granted protection to the Japanese porn films only out of obligation to its international agreements.

The decision implied that domestically owned pornographic copyrights are not protected in Taiwan. This dichotomy is permissible under Berne and TRIPs, because those agreements require that member states treat citizens of all other member states equally, but the agreements give members states the right to discriminate against their own citizens. 

In any event, it now seems that Taiwan is no longer a porn-piracy free-fire zone.

As far as Taiwanese producers go, they may still find themselves without a legal remedy. However, this is easily cured. If the producers simply create a foreign corporation, that corporation can be the initial copyright owner. At that point, the Taiwanese courts will be obliged to protect the works, even if the beneficial owners of the works are still Taiwanese nationals. 

Marc Randazza is the managing partner at Randazza Legal Group. The firm has offices in Las Vegas and Miami, both specializing in intellectual property, First Amendment and Internet law. The author recently completed an LLM degree in international intellectual property Law administered by the World Intellectual Property Organization and the University of Turin Faculty of Law in Italy.

(c) Marc Randazza.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Haley Spades Stars in Latest From Immoral

Haley Spades stars with Charlie Dean, Matt Bird, and Dean Van Damme in a new three-part release from Immoral Productions, directed by "Porno Dan" Leal.

Octavia Red Makes Her Vampired Debut

Octavia Red has made her Vampired debut alongside Talia Mint and 2023 XMA Europas Female Performer of the Year Tiffany Tatum in the new feature “Hunters.”

Lily Starfire Fronts Latest From Brazzers

Lily Starfire stars with Kyle Mason in the latest release from Brazzers, titled "Eating Ass Is the Game."

Country Hotwife Makes Her WIFEY Debut

Content creator Country Hotwife has made her debut for Vixen Media Group (VMG) studio imprint WIFEY, alongside her husband StagHubby and former XMAs Male Performer of the Year Isiah Maxwell.

Vixen Media Group Celebrates 10 Years of 'Tushy'

Vixen Media Group (VMG) is celebrating the 10-year anniversary of studio imprint Tushy.

Cherry Kiss Stars in Latest 'Blind Dates' From Bellesa

Cherry Kiss headlines the 16th volume of "Blind Dates," from Bellesa.

Emma Rosie Toplines Pat Myne's 'Gape For Days 5'

Emma Rosie headlines director Pat Myne's "Gape For Days 5," from Evil Angel.

Adult Time Drops 2nd Installment of Bree Mills Thriller 'Escape From Camp Conversion'

Adult Time has debuted the second episode of the Bree Mills-helmed thriller "Escape From Camp Conversion," from studio brand Girlcore.

UPDATED: Supreme Court Rules Against Adult Industry in Pivotal Texas AV Case

The U.S. Supreme Court on Friday issued its decision in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, striking a blow against the online adult industry by ruling in support of Texas’ controversial age verification law, HB 1181.

Eris Jolie Makes Her TransAngels Debut

Eris Jolie has made her TransAngels debut alongside Bree Brooks in "A Very Filthy Cookout."

Show More