Lawyers Cry Foul Over Adam Walsh Amendment to 2257

RICHMOND, Va. — Computer forensic experts and an attorney who handles obscenity cases have testified in court that a new federal law makes it difficult for them to defend clients accused of downloading child pornography.

Lawyers for David Knellinger have asked U.S. District Court Judge Robert Payne to strike down a provision in the Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act, which President Bush signed last July.

The provision prevents lawyers and forensic experts from obtaining copies of child porn contraband that would assist in preparing their client’s defense. Existing conditions force lawyers and forensic experts to work in government laboratories.

“An expert likes to work in his own laboratory,” attorney H. Louis Sirkin, an expert witness in the Knellinger case, told XBIZ. “If he can’t do it in his own laboratory, he simply won’t get involved. They also like to use their own equipment and the cost of simulating that in a government laboratory would be astronomical.”

Sirkin explained that experts need to study the contraband videos to learn whether they are real or virtual.

“You have to do a mirror digital image, and you have to compare it,” Sirkin explained. “They have to go through variations to learn whether it’s a virtual child or a real child, when it was downloaded and other things. So it’s not just a matter of turning a switch and taking a look at a picture.”

Sirkin added that the Supreme Court has indicated that a virtual image of a child is not child pornography, and therefore is not a crime.

The provision of the Adam Walsh law under attack in the Knellinger case states that the child pornography material cannot be viewed outside the control of the government, according to Sirkin.

“Equal justice for all means equal to the defendant as well as the government,” Sirkin said. “We should all be playing on the same ground. We want to view the evidence in the same uninhibited environment that the government has.

“But somewhere in the Department of Justice, they don’t want equal justice. They want one-sided justice, and I don’t know where that lesson has been lost.”

Knellinger is charged with four counts of receiving child porn, and one count each of possession and attempted distribution.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Sinatra Monroe on Channeling Vintage Glamour Into Modern Stardom

For Sinatra Monroe, her professional name is more than just a catchy stage moniker. “The name is my homage to Frank Sinatra and Marilyn Monroe,” she explains. “I would have loved to be in Hollywood and Las Vegas during that time. I definitely have two sides, and my Sinatra Monroe side lets me express my creativity and sexuality.”

MyMember.site Debuts Watermark Feature

MyMember.site has introduced a watermark feature to its platform.

Victoria Rey Makes Her WIFEY Debut

Creator Victoria Rey has made her debut for new Vixen Media Group (VMG) studio imprint WIFEY alongside her husband Leo and Dante Colle.

Evil Angel Debuts Proxy Paige's 'Crossing Borders 2'

Evil Angel has released director Proxy Paige’s new title, “Crossing Borders 2.”

Kazumi Stars in New Gangbang From Ricky's Room

Kazumi stars in the newest gangbang release from Ricky's Room, with Chocolate God, Derek Savage, Hollywood Cash, Mannie Coco, Mazee The Goat, and studio honcho Ricky Johnson.

Taboo Porn: A Look at the Ethics and Allure of the Forbidden

Taboo lurks on the edge of human curiosity, where power, transgression and fantasy collide. Taboo turns the illicit into the irresistible, appealing to our deepest, most secret urges.

Missouri AG Bypasses Legislature, Declares Age Verification Rule

Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey on Wednesday announced a new state regulation requiring adult sites to implement age verification of users, bypassing the legislative process in a strategy not seen before in state-level efforts to mandate age verification.

Kelsi Monroe, Asteria Jade Front Latest From Reality Kings

Kelsi Monroe and Asteria Jade star with Derek Savage in the latest release from Reality Kings, titled "Money Talks: Ren Faire."

TeamSkeet Announces 'Fan Fantasy Month' Cross-Site Promo

TeamSkeet, MYLF, Swappz, Freeuse, and Pervz have partnered for a cross-site promotion called Fan Fantasy Month.

Blake Blossom Returns to New Sensations

Blake Blossom stars with Damon Dice in the latest release from New Sensations, titled “In the Room.”

Show More