Appeals Court Reverses Ruling on Importation, Sale of Couples Vibrators

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit today overturned a ruling barring the importation and sale of U-shaped couples vibrators that had been found to infringe on a patent held by Standard Innovation Corp.

In Monday's ruling, the Washington-based appeals court reversed a June 2013 decision by the U.S. International Trade Commission and ruled for LELO Inc., which for years has been fighting with rival Standard Innovation over its patent as well as sale and importation of two-armed or dual-motor vibrator couples vibrators.

The International Trade Commission only has power to protect a business or industry that has significant levels of research and development or employment in the U.S.

Ottawa-based Standard Innovation filed a suit in early 2012 accusing a number of companies led by San Jose, Calif.- and Stockholm-based LELO of infringing on its patent covering the We-Vibe.

The Federal Circuit, in overturning the International Trade Commission ruling, said Standard Innovation's investment and employment levels in the U.S. lacked satisfying "domestic industry requirements." The court, however, did not rule on the validity of Standard Innovation's intellectual property registered under U.S. Patent No. 7,931,605.

The court, in its opinion, said that Standard Innovation uses Chinese manufacturers to assemble the We-Vibe devices, from parts and components obtained from third-party suppliers, and fell short of the requirements for protection tied to a patent.

“We hold that qualitative factors alone are insufficient to show ‘significant investment in plant and equipment’ and ‘significant employment of labor or capital’ under [several prongs] of the § 337 domestic industry requirements,” the appellate court ruled today.

“The purchase of so called ‘crucial’ components from third-party U.S. suppliers are insufficient to satisfy the ‘significant investment’ or ‘significant employment of labor or capital’ criteria of § 337 where there is an absence of evidence that connects the cost of the components to an increase of investment or employment in the U.S.”

Standard Innovation spokesman Denny Alexander told Reuters today that it had not yet decided whether to seek a rehearing of the case.

Alexander, however, said that Standard Innovation would view any resumption of import and sales of We-Vibe competitors by LELO or others as "willful infringement."

"While disappointed in the ruling we're still optimistic in the validity of our patent," Alexander told Reuters. “The patent office has reconfirmed time and again that our patent is valid.”

LELO officials were not immediately available for XBIZ comment on the ruling.

View today's ruling

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Blush Partners With South Korean Wellness Brand Red Container

Blush has partnered with South Korean wellness brand Red Container on a number of pleasure product collaborations.

Swiss Navy Debuts New Variety Packs

Swiss Navy has introduced two new personal lubricant variety packs.

BasisDx Adds Expedited Results Option for 'Pro13' Home Testing Kit

PASS-certified home testing kit provider BasisDx has added a new option for expedited test results for its Pro13 kit.

Kiiroo, Pineapple Support Launch 'Empower Hour' Series on FeelHubX YouTube Channel

Kiiroo and Pineapple Support have teamed up to launch the “Empower Hour” series on the FeelHubX YouTube channel.

Kansas Law Firm Deploys Religion, Bunk Science While Recruiting Plaintiffs Under AV Law

Kansas-based personal injury law firm Mann Wyatt Tanksley is promoting debunked scientific theories and leveraging religious affiliation against the industry while it seeks potential plaintiffs for lawsuits against adult companies under the state’s age verification law.

UK Tech Secretary Lists Age Verification Among OSA Priorities

Peter Kyle, the U.K.’s Secretary of State for Science, Innovation and Technology, on Wednesday made public a draft version of his priorities for implementing the Online Safety Act (OSA), including age verification.

Orion Debuts 'Suck-O-Mat 3' Masturbator

Orion Wholesale has introduced the third edition of its Suck-O-Mat masturbator.

Biird Debuts 'Ohwii' Glass Dildo

Biird has introduced Ohwii, its new double-ended glass dildo.

Sportsheets Releases New Training Video for 'Edge' Line

Sportsheets has released its latest training video, titled "Edge Product Training," the third in a series hosted by Brand Ambassador Rin Musick.

Exsens Marks Its 10th Anniversary

Intimate wellness and body care brand Exsens is celebrating its 10-year anniversary.

Show More