Pink Visual, Motherless Argue Infringement Case in Front of 9th Circuit

Pink Visual, Motherless Argue Infringement Case in Front of 9th Circuit

PASADENA, Calif. — The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals today heard Pink Visual’s appeal over a federal court ruling made in 2013 that granted summary judgment to adult tube site Motherless.com in an infringement case.

Adult studio Pink Visual sued Motherless in 2012 after its employees found 19 copyrighted films, including 33 scenes, owned by Pink Visual's parent company, Ventura Content, on the tube site.

But the case was dismissed on summary judgment after U.S. District Judge Stephen Wilson in Los Angeles ruled that Motherless' operators were entitled to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act's safe-harbor provisions as an Internet service provider.

The gravamen of Pink Visual's claims in the case was that Motherless hadn't “reasonably” implemented effective procedures, including expelling “repeat infringers,” for dealing with DMCA-complaint notifications over poached content. 

On Monday, 9th Circuit Judges Jacqueline Nguyen, Johnnie Rawlinson and Andrew Kleinfeld listened to arguments in the case made by Pink Visual appellate counsel Peter Afrasiabi and Motherless appellate counsel David Richman.

Motherless, one of the largest adult tube sites on the web, has grown into a behemoth with 750,000 members and about 12 million tube site entries since it became established in 2008.

In describing Motherless’ operation, Afrasiabi told the court that the tube site and its owner, Joshua Lange, run it with “zero license deals” from adult filmmakers and that “their business is infringement and the monetization [of poached content].”

“Ninety percent [of the scenes and full-length features on the site] are infringement,” Afrasiabi said.

But in its defense and support of its contention that it had “reasonably” implemented its repeat-infringer policy, Richman noted that all take down notices were complied with — but only if DMCA notices were properly submitted and included each and every aspect required for such.

Richman noted that Motherless has terminated between 1,300 and 2,000 users for various reasons, including alleged copyright infringement.

Pink Visual identified nine Motherless users — eight users who uploaded the 19 films at center of the case, as well as one other user — it alleged are infringers who should have been terminated but were not.

In its decision whether to allow the case to be heard in front of a jury at district court, the 9th Circuit will focus on whether the lower court abused its discretion in making a summary judgment ruling in the infringement case.

Wilson, the district court judge, earlier ruled that "the DMCA requires only that the policy be 'reasonably'— not 'perfectly' — implemented, and thus “occasional lapses are not fatal to the service provider’s immunity.”

To view today's hearing, click here.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

New EU User Stats Could Reclassify Major Adult Sites Under DSA

Three high-traffic adult sites previously classified as “very large online platforms” under the European Union’s Digital Services Act are reporting user numbers below the threshold for that label, opening the way for possible downgrading of their obligations under that law.

Spicerack Launches 'SpicyFanz' Creator Monetization Platform

Adult product marketplace Spicerack Market has launched its SpicyFanz creator monetization platform.

Singapore Livestreamer Jailed for Performing 'Obscene Acts' in Public

A judge in Singapore on Thursday sentenced a Vietnamese woman to three weeks in jail for livestreaming “obscene acts” from a public area.

FSC Withdraws Support for North Dakota AV Bill

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has withdrawn its support for an age verification bill in North Dakota, following changes made by the state legislature.

APClips Launches New Blog

APClips has launched a blog, AmateurPorn.com.

Centrobill Launches 'Max' Payment Suite

Payment processing service Centrobill has launched its new Max Suite toolkit.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches by Country for December, January

AEBN has released the list of popular searches from its straight and gay theaters by country in December and January.

South Dakota Legislators Debate AV Legal Strategies

The South Dakota state Senate Judiciary Committee on Tuesday heard testimony and debate over two competing age verification bills, in a hearing that focused largely on which piece of legislation could best withstand potential legal challenges.

Mobile OnlyFans Management Platform 'TopCreator' Launches

Mobile OnlyFans management and chat platform TopCreator has launched.

JustFor.fans Marks Its 7th Anniversary With Palm Springs Conference

JustFor.fans is celebrating its seventh anniversary with a four-day conference and party in Palm Springs May 18-21.

Show More