Sex Trafficking Bill Designed to Poke Holes in Section 230 Immunity

Sex Trafficking Bill Designed to Poke Holes in Section 230 Immunity

WASHINGTON — A new proposal that tweaks Section 230 immunity of the Communication Decency Act could have major ramifications for online publishers and platforms.

The specific draft bill circulating through Congress, called the “No Immunity for Sex Traffickers Online Act of 2017,” would ensure “vigorous” criminal enforcement,” along with civil remedies, for victims against publishers, platforms and users relating to sexual exploitation.

Section 230, as it stands today, protects online publishers and platforms from being held liable for items that third parties post — at least when it comes to state crimes and civil lawsuits.

The bill, if signed into law, would allow states to indict any online publisher or platform that introduces an underage person to a potential buyer of sex as a conspirator in sex trafficking. It also would allow underage persons paid for sex to subsequently sue any publisher or platform involved in the transaction.

The “No Immunity for Sex Traffickers Online Act of 2017,” introduced by Rep. Wagner, appears to target services like Backpage.com, which in January abruptly bowed to pressure and replaced its online sex ads with the word “censored” in red.

Backpage.com’s move came in the midst of a Senate probe, two federal lawsuits, a federal grand jury inquiry in Arizona and criminal charges in California accusing its operators of pimping underage persons.

But while the "No Immunity" bill focuses on Backpage.com-centric online entities, the piece of legislation, if passed, could initiate prosecution and civil suits against other internet entities that allow content posted by users.

Industry attorney Lawrence Walters of Walters Law Group told XBIZ that the proposal is flawed because creating loopholes in Section 230 immunity undermines “core First Amendment principles” designed to protect the free flow of information online.

“Section 230 immunity is broad for a reason,” Walters said. “Holding online service providers responsible for any category of wrongful actions by their users, however narrow, imposes an intolerable burden on those companies to review each and every piece of content flowing through their servers for potential liability. 

''Imposing that kind of burden on internet service providers will stifle online innovation and result in huge collateral damage on existing companies — some of whom may choose to shut down as opposed to operating in a climate where they can be held liable for abuse of their system by a user."

Walters noted that the retroactive provisions of the draft bill create “some significant due process concerns, since providers could be held liable for conduct that was protected by Section 230 when it actually occurred.”

“Legislation like this puts lawmakers in a difficult position, because they’re seemingly forced to take a politically unpopular stand against relief for sex trafficking victims, if they vote against it,” Walters said. “However, politicians took an oath to uphold the Constitution, including the First Amendment. Section 230 is a reflection of our nation’s commitment to free speech.”    

Eric Paul Leue, the executive director of the Free Speech Coalition, upon comment, said that the the House bill “should frighten anyone who works in any sex-related industry.”

“At a time when many states are moving toward decriminalizing consensual sex work, the legislation would destroy platforms and protections that have helped make consensual sex work safer and push those workers underground,” Leue told XBIZ. “This is why even anti-trafficking groups have voiced concerns about this misguided legislation.

“We also worry about the revocation of these protections in a period in which we simultaneously see legislators and law enforcement apply the term ‘sex trafficking,’ not only to the insidious crime of human trafficking, to consensual sex work, including consensually produced adult entertainment. 

“This will have no deterrent effect on actual sex trafficking, but would create huge liabilities for anyone working in or advocating for the adult industry,” Leue said. “It would have a chilling effect on sexual speech and is intended to make ISPs and search engines fearful of carrying any form of sexual content.” 

View bill

Related:  

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Signature Partners With BunnyCMS for Secure Payment Processing

Signature Payments has partnered with adult content management platform BunnyCMS to offer creators secure payment processing.

Sexologist Dr. Susan Block Files Motion in Meta Lawsuit

Sexologist Dr. Susan Block has reported she has filed a Motion to Vacate with a California court after an arbitrator threw out her case against Meta in June.

JustFor.fans Launches BlueSky Autoposting Feature

JustFor.fans has launched a new BlueSky autoposting feature that shares JFF posts on the social media platform.

Pineapple Support Introduces 'Sacred Rage' Support Group for Performers, Creators

Pineapple Support will host a free online support group for performers and creators, designed for individuals struggling with intense emotions and the pain often hidden behind their anger.

FSC: Kansas Attorneys Seeking Plaintiffs to Sue Adult Companies Over Age Verification

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has released a statement warning that a personal injury law firm in Kansas is soliciting plaintiffs to sue adult companies under the state's age verification law.

Ukrainian Parliament Registers Bill to Decriminalize Porn

Ukraine's parliament, the Verkhovna Rada, registered a bill today to decriminalize the creation and distribution of pornography.

Cherie DeVille Guests on 'Sex Tales' Podcast

2023 XBIZ Performer of the Year Cherie DeVille is the latest guest on the "Sex Tales" podcast, hosted by Melissa Stratton and Vanniall, streaming on the company’s “Camming Life” YouTube channel.

Niki Media Acquires BritSexCash

Production studio Niki Media BV has acquired affiliate program BritSexCash.

FSC Warns of Nude Photography Site Falsely Claiming Affiliation With Organization

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) published a statement Friday warning of a nude art photography website fraudulently claiming to be associated with the industry trade organization.

MojoHost Reaffirms Commitment to Adult Industry Amid Project 2025 Implications

In the wake of Tuesday’s election and concerns about Project 2025’s potential ramifications, MojoHost President Brad Mitchell has released a statement affirming its commitment to the adult industry.

Show More