FSC Tackles Issue of Limited Injunctive Relief in 2257 Case

FSC Tackles Issue of Limited Injunctive Relief in 2257 Case

PHILADELPHIA — The Free Speech Coalition late yesterday issued a memorandum to a federal judge hearing ongoing proceedings over 18 U.S.C. §§ 2257 and 2257A, asking the court for a final judgment to declare the federal recordkeeping laws unconstitutional and to enjoin their enforcement.

The long-running case over the legality of the recordkeeping law for adult producers hit a fork in the road several months ago after U.S. District Judge Michael Baylson ordered the adult entertainment trade group to work with the Justice Department to attempt to resolve First Amendment issues and formulate a judgment that conformed to decisions the court has already made.

The court presented a draft judgment entry that included declaratory and injunctive relief in favor of the FSC on their as-applied challenges under the First Amendment, but it limited injunctive relief to individuals who were named in the complaint.

However, the FSC contends that under "strict scrutiny" there is little, if any, difference between an as-applied and facial challenge and that there are precedents that require a statute to be unenforceable in totality. (Strict scrutiny is a legal standard of review to determine which is weightier: a constitutional right or principle or the government's interest against observance of the principle.)

“Because this court found that the laws were unconstitutional under the First Amendment as applied, the government argues that declaratory and injunctive relief must consequently be limited to the individual plaintiffs before the court,” FSC attorneys J. Michael Murray and Lorraine Baumgarder noted in the memorandum.

FSC counsel also said that “confusion exists about the differences (or lack thereof) between facial, as-applied, and overbreadth challenges in varying contexts under the First Amendment.”

“Under strict scrutiny, there is little, if any, difference between an as-applied and facial challenge ….  In case after case, when the court determined a content-based regulation of speech could not survive strict scrutiny, it struck it down in its entirety; it did not limit relief to the individual plaintiffs who challenged it,” FSC counsel said.

FSC attorneys also pointed out that they appreciated Baylson’s efforts in proposing alternative solutions, such as adding language indicating plaintiffs are suing on behalf of themselves and “all others similarly situated” but that, absent the government’s agreement to not take action against individual producers, the proposals wouldn’t be workable.

Without the Justice Department’s agreement, “entry of final judgment would be unduly delayed on collateral procedural issues in the face of the government’s likely opposition that would require briefing and resolution by the court,” FSC counsel said.

In addition, the adult entertainment trade group said that discussions between the parties on submitting a new proposed regulation for labeling material subject to the statutes should be delayed.

The FSC has proposed an outline of a new simple, straightforward labeling regulation requiring primary producers of visual depictions of actual and simulated sexually explicit conduct to affix a label to such visual depictions stating that all persons appearing in those depictions are 18 years of age or older.

“But in light of the government’s position that the Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. §§ 701–06) does not permit it to submit a proposed regulation to the court, plaintiffs contend the best option is to defer that issue until after any appeals are concluded,” the FSC counsel wrote.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Chloe Amour Stars in Latest From Tushy

Chloe Amour stars with Alberto Blanco in the latest release from Vixen Media Group (VMG) studio imprint Tushy.

EroSpain Announces 2025 Conference in Barcelona

EroSpain will hold its third B2B exposition in Barcelona, May 25-27.

Nubiles Signs Emma Rosie to Exclusive Contract

Nubiles has added Emma Rosie to its roster of exclusive performers.

Eva Maxim Leads AEBN's 'Top 10 Trans Stars' of 2024

AEBN has revealed its top trans stars of 2024 based on scene and movie sales, with Eva Maxim in the number one spot.

X3 Expo to Host 'Top Studs' Panel With All-Star Lineup

X3 Expo organizers have unveiled the panel “Hard Lessons: Top Studs Spill Their Secrets,” set to be held Jan. 17 at 7 p.m.

Pineapple Support Launches 'Spill the Tea Romania' Event Series

Pineapple Support has launched its Spill the Tea Romania community event.

Segpay Adds SEPA Payment Solution

Segpay has added a SEPA (Single Euro Payments Area) option to its direct payments solutions.

Holly Randall Launches Lifestyle Mag 'XSIV'

Holly Randall has officially launched her new lifestyle publication, XSIV Magazine.

Adult Time Drops Latest Installment of Jim Powers' 'MILF Overload'

Adult Time has released the latest installment of director Jim Powers' series "MILF Overload."

Hentaied Launches Fetish Sites Smoking Hawt, Tickling Launch

Two new fetish paysites, SmokingHawt.com and Tickling.com, have officially launched from the creator of Hentaied.com."Smoking has always been one of the most popular fetishes," said a rep. "The ability to get off just by watching someone smoke is one of the oldest fetishes."

Show More