U.S. Justices Won't Hear DMCA Safe-Harbor Case Waged by Pink Visual

U.S. Justices Won't Hear DMCA Safe-Harbor Case Waged by Pink Visual

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday denied Pink Visual’s petition to review its copyright infringement lawsuit against adult tube site Motherless.com.

Pink Visual’s parent, Ventura Content, had sought a decision by justices in a case that focused plainly on the Digital Millennium Copyright Act's safe-harbor provisions.

The adult company, once a commanding web platform for original adult content, alleged Motherless.com hadn't implemented effective procedures, including expelling repeat infringers, for dealing with DMCA-complaint notifications over stolen content. It contended in court proceedings that Motherless.com wasn’t merely a passive receptacle of postings over which it exercises no control.

Pink Visual sued Motherless after 19 copyrighted films, including 33 scenes, owned by the web platform, were found on the adult tube site.

In its petition that was denied by the court on Monday, Pink Visual’s counsel, Peter Afrasiabi, told U.S. justices that review of the case was warranted because a split exists in U.S. appeals courts on the meaning of a “reasonable termination policy for repeat infringers” under 17 U.S.C. § 512 (i), which spells out conditions for eligibility in regards to liability relating to material online.

It also said that review is warranted on 17 U.S.C. § 512 (c) over liability in regards to where information resides on systems and networks.

“Because the 9th Circuit has eviscerated the principle that actual and apparent knowledge of mass infringing activity using one’s wares serves as a basis for copyright liability of Grokster,” Afrasiabi said.

The high court’s ruling in Grokster held that peer-to-peer file sharing companies can be sued for inducing infringement for acts taken in the course of marketing file-sharing software.

Prior to the appeal at the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, the case was dismissed in 2013 on summary judgment after U.S. District Judge Stephen Wilson in Los Angeles ruled that Motherless' operators were entitled to the DMCA's safe-harbor provisions as an ISP.

Afrasiabi, in a brief to the Supreme Court to take up the case on behalf of Pink Visual’s parent, said that federal courts are creating “a new monster” by allowing full immunity to online pirates.

“The lower courts, acting out of a fear of derailing the internet’s development have instead given birth to a new monster: the online service provider publisher that is brazenly rich only from others’ content, never pays for any content it publishes, knows the content is infringing, has full control over what is published on its platform, does not have to terminate known repeat infringers because unwritten ‘I know repeat infringement when I see it’ policies suffice, and thus enjoys full immunity from copyright law,” Afrasiabi wrote.

“It is time for this court to bring balance to the DMCA, which never intended, nor facially permits, such staggering dissonance between online and offline liability standards.”

On Monday, however, hopes of a high court review of the DMCA's safe-harbor provisions were dashed.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Adult Time Wraps Production on Bree Mills' Feature 'Escape From Camp Conversion'

Adult Time has wrapped production on its latest feature, the Bree Mills-helmed "Escape From Camp Conversion," from its Girlcore studio brand.

Daisy Fox Makes Her TeamSkeet Debut

Daisy Fox makes her TeamSkeet debut in the latest episode of the studio series "She's New," titled "A Foxy Little Newcomer," with Nicky Rebel.

Elizabeth Skylar Performs Her 1st B/B/G in Latest From New Sensations

Elizabeth Skylar has performed her first B/B/G in the latest scene from New Sensations, with Codey Steele and Milan Ponjevic.

ImLive Launches Revamped Member Loyalty Program

Cam platform ImLive has revamped its member loyalty program.

Lynna Nilsson Fronts Latest From Immoral Productions

Lynna Nilsson performs her first DVP in a new trilogy from Immoral Productions, alongside Matt Bird and Brad Knight.

Anna Claire Clouds: From Nashville to XMA Gold

The photo shoot is going great. Anna Claire Clouds knows all her angles. The moment the cap comes off the camera lens, Clouds tilts her head just so and deploys her signature dreamy eyes with all controls set to “smoldering.” Girl knows what she’s doing.

Lilly Bell Takes the Spotlight in 2 New Adult Time Scenes

2025 XMAs Girl/Girl Performer of the Year Lilly Bell stars in two new scenes from Adult Time.

LorReign Makes Her WIFEY Debut

Content creator and former Colorado sheriff's deputy LorReign has made her debut for new Vixen Media Group (VMG) studio imprint WIFEY alongside her husband Anthony and Jax Slayher.

Angela White Stars in Latest From Brazzers

Angela White stars with Derek Savage in the latest release from Brazzers, titled “Boom Boom Angela.”

GoFundMe Set Up for Danny Ferretti's Medical Expenses

A GoFundMe campaign has been set up for Fangear founder Danny Ferretti, who requires extensive lung surgery.

Show More