Utah Legislator Behind Anti-Porn Bill Once Penned Defense of Homophobic Speech

Utah Legislator Behind Anti-Porn Bill Once Penned Defense of Homophobic Speech

SALT LAKE CITY — Brady Brammer, the Utah legislator who is sponsoring the current bill that would force all "obscene material" distributed in the state, including via the internet, to attach an unnecessary and unconstitutional warning that the material "may damage or negatively impact minors," authored a 2006 essay arguing for the equivalence of gay rights speech and religiously inspired homophobic speech, and asking for the latter to be protected.

In his 2006 Brigham Young University Law Review paper "Religious Groups and the Gay Rights Movement: Recognizing Common Ground" (.pdf attached below), Brammer concluded that "in the wake of unrestrained equality-based claims, the nation could potentially reach a time when religious groups could not take a moral stance of conscience against homosexuality. The question then becomes whether that should happen. In the interest of both groups and future groups to come, the answer is a resounding 'no.'"

Throughout 39 pages filled with clunky analogies and references to literary works, Brammer makes the perverse argument that "religious groups" — which he narrows down to mean those religious groups or individuals with vocal policies against gay rights or homosexuality in general — and "the gay rights movement" both have equal standing in terms of free speech.

In his paper, Brammer deliberately ignores that one group is actively campaigning to prevent numerous LGBTQ Americans, whether they are an active part of his "gay rights movement" group or not, from obtaining full rights under the constitution.

A Misleading Title

The title of the essay is a misleading attempt to create a sense of amity between religiously inspired homophobes and those people fighting for the rights that the homophobes seek to deny. Brammer wanted the legal establishment to recognize that there's "common ground" between anti-gay activists and gay right advocates — essentially, free speech.

This is in marked contrast to Brammer's current-day attempt to impose an onerous and unconstitutional mandate on all sexual expression worldwide if any material he considers "obscene" happens to be distributed in his home state of Utah.

According to adult industry trade group Free Speech Coalition (FSC), Brammer's bill, HB243, which has easily cleared the Utah House and Senate and is on its way to the governor's desk, would make anyone who does not comply liable to be sued by the Attorney General of Utah, for a penalty of $2,500 per violation. This would presumably include not only studios around the world but also cam performers and individual clip artists.

As the FSC pointed out, HB243 "remains a land mine of First Amendment issues. Affixing a state-mandated warning to an adult film, which enjoys First Amendment protections, is fundamentally different from doing the same to a food product, which does not."

Brammer, according to the FSC, says that "the labeling law will only apply to 'obscene' content. However, there is no established legal definition for obscenity — each case would have to be worked out through a lengthy and expensive legal process. However, the chilling effect on legal speech would be substantial."

Brammer, a Republican representative and successful lawyer in Utah, often flaunts his connection to Brigham Young University, its Law School and the Law Review where, in 2006, he passionately pled for free speech protections for homophobic activists.

After considering "tensions between the gay rights movement and religious speech condemning homosexuality" — this was the era of the fight for the recognition of gay marriage — Brammer drew two conclusions: "First, it is possible for the gay rights movement to advance their goals through the legal suppression of religious speech opposing homosexuality. Second, such a strategy would injure religious groups and gay rights activists by eroding fundamental freedoms of conscience that both groups rely upon."

In 2016, Utah became the first state to adopt a resolution endorsing a "public health crisis" around porn. Over 15 other state legislatures have since adopted similar copycat measures, with language provided by religiously inspired lobbies and copied from state to state. These bills are usually sponsored by religious legislators, often fundamentalist evangelicals, with various appeals to War On Porn propaganda scares around "sex trafficking" and the debunked notion of "porn addiction."

Brady Brammer's 2006 Law Review Essay Arguing for the Free Speech of Religious Homophobes

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Adult Time Marks April Fool's Day With 5 Satirical Releases

Adult Time is marking April Fool’s Day with the release of satirical scenes from five of its series.

Pineapple Support to Host Autism Spectrum Support Group

Pineapple Support is hosting a free online support group for performers and creators who are, or suspect they may be, on the autism spectrum.

Adult Time Wraps Production on Bree Mills' Feature 'Escape From Camp Conversion'

Adult Time has wrapped production on its latest feature, the Bree Mills-helmed "Escape From Camp Conversion," from its Girlcore studio brand.

Daisy Fox Makes Her TeamSkeet Debut

Daisy Fox makes her TeamSkeet debut in the latest episode of the studio series "She's New," titled "A Foxy Little Newcomer," with Nicky Rebel.

Elizabeth Skylar Performs Her 1st B/B/G in Latest From New Sensations

Elizabeth Skylar has performed her first B/B/G in the latest scene from New Sensations, with Codey Steele and Milan Ponjevic.

ImLive Launches Revamped Member Loyalty Program

Cam platform ImLive has revamped its member loyalty program.

Lynna Nilsson Fronts Latest From Immoral Productions

Lynna Nilsson performs her first DVP in a new trilogy from Immoral Productions, alongside Matt Bird and Brad Knight.

Anna Claire Clouds: From Nashville to XMA Gold

The photo shoot is going great. Anna Claire Clouds knows all her angles. The moment the cap comes off the camera lens, Clouds tilts her head just so and deploys her signature dreamy eyes with all controls set to “smoldering.” Girl knows what she’s doing.

Lilly Bell Takes the Spotlight in 2 New Adult Time Scenes

2025 XMAs Girl/Girl Performer of the Year Lilly Bell stars in two new scenes from Adult Time.

LorReign Makes Her WIFEY Debut

Content creator and former Colorado sheriff's deputy LorReign has made her debut for new Vixen Media Group (VMG) studio imprint WIFEY alongside her husband Anthony and Jax Slayher.

Show More