Split Appeals Decision Highlights Rift Over DMCA Notice Handling

Split Appeals Decision Highlights Rift Over DMCA Notice Handling

PASADENA, Calif. — A two-to-one split vote in the U.S. Circuit Court for the Ninth Circuit last week spotlighted the ongoing controversy over internet infrastructure companies' responsibility for illegal content. Two of the three judges on the panel sided with data-center service Steadfast Networks LLC over copyright owners ALS Scan Inc.

Friday’s decision endorsed server farm operator Steadfast Network's view that it had done its due diligence by forwarding Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) notices issued by ALS Scan for pirated content to the platform that had hosted them.

That platform, ImageBam.com, was cited in a Bloomberg Law report as having become “a hub for infringing adult content.” However, the Ninth Circuit panel’s narrow majority was convinced that Steadfast Networks had done enough to combat infringement by forwarding the DMCA notices to ImageBam, resulting in “timely removal of the material.”

The split decision, the Bloomberg Law reporter commented, “highlights the question of how much responsibility the DMCA places on operators of internet infrastructure to address repeated infringement via their services.”

A central issue was what the litigants referred to as “the whack-a-mole problem,” a result of the DMCA’s notice-and-takedown provisions that has led to endless infringer-chasing for copyright owners.

“We are sympathetic to ALS’s ‘whack-a-mole problem,’” the court admitted in the unpublished (i.e., not to be quoted as precedent) opinion, “but we are persuaded by the specific facts of this case that Steadfast’s ‘simple measures’ are enough.”

Steadfast, the opinion continued, “forwarded each notice to ImageBam’s owner, and every infringing work was taken down. Nor is there evidence that Steadfast had any other simple measures at its disposal. Steadfast did not operate, control or manage any functions of ImageBam.com. It could not supervise, access, locate or delete ImageBam accounts. It had no way of knowing, based on a URL hyperlink contained in the notices of copyright infringement, where the infringing works or the ImageBam accounts responsible for illegal uploads were located on [the] servers.”

The panel heard the case “de novo” — “anew” in Latin — a common appeals strategy in civil and small claim cases where one of the parties continues to fight a case after a ruling against them. The trial de novo request asks to set aside the decisions from a lower court and re-try the case.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

New EU User Stats Could Reclassify Major Adult Sites Under DSA

Three high-traffic adult sites previously classified as “very large online platforms” under the European Union’s Digital Services Act are reporting user numbers below the threshold for that label, opening the way for possible downgrading of their obligations under that law.

Spicerack Launches 'SpicyFanz' Creator Monetization Platform

Adult product marketplace Spicerack Market has launched its SpicyFanz creator monetization platform.

Singapore Livestreamer Jailed for Performing 'Obscene Acts' in Public

A judge in Singapore on Thursday sentenced a Vietnamese woman to three weeks in jail for livestreaming “obscene acts” from a public area.

FSC Withdraws Support for North Dakota AV Bill

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has withdrawn its support for an age verification bill in North Dakota, following changes made by the state legislature.

APClips Launches New Blog

APClips has launched a blog, AmateurPorn.com.

Centrobill Launches 'Max' Payment Suite

Payment processing service Centrobill has launched its new Max Suite toolkit.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches by Country for December, January

AEBN has released the list of popular searches from its straight and gay theaters by country in December and January.

South Dakota Legislators Debate AV Legal Strategies

The South Dakota state Senate Judiciary Committee on Tuesday heard testimony and debate over two competing age verification bills, in a hearing that focused largely on which piece of legislation could best withstand potential legal challenges.

Mobile OnlyFans Management Platform 'TopCreator' Launches

Mobile OnlyFans management and chat platform TopCreator has launched.

JustFor.fans Marks Its 7th Anniversary With Palm Springs Conference

JustFor.fans is celebrating its seventh anniversary with a four-day conference and party in Palm Springs May 18-21.

Show More