5th Circuit Hears Arguments in Texas Age Verification Challenge

5th Circuit Hears Arguments in Texas Age Verification Challenge

AUSTIN, Texas — A three-judge panel of the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday heard arguments regarding the injunction against enforcement of Texas’ controversial age verification law, which mandates that adult websites post anti-porn propaganda.

Texas authorities asked the panel to lift the injunction, which was obtained on Aug. 31 by Free Speech Coalition (FSC) and other plaintiffs. HB 1181 was passed by the Texas legislature with bipartisan support in May and was scheduled to go into effect Sept. 1.

As XBIZ reported, on Sept. 21 the 5th Circuit judges issued an administrative stay of the injunction in a two-sentence ruling that offered no details or explanations.

The injunction — issued by Senior U.S. District Judge David Ezra, a Ronald Reagan appointee — blocks the Texas attorney general from enforcing the Republican-authored anti-porn age verification law while the case is litigated.

Judge Ezra “agreed with the plaintiffs that HB 1181 violates the First Amendment by forcing websites to speak Texas’ preferred messages — the health advisories that he determined were ‘somewhat deceptive’ because the state had not shown its Health and Human Services Commission had made medical findings to back the claims,” Courthouse News reported.

Judge Ezra’s reasoning, which mentioned Section 230 protections, also questioned Texas’ approach to age verification technologies, pointing out the risk of accidental disclosures, hacks and leaks.

On Wednesday, Texas Assistant AG John Ramsey claimed Judge Ezra “misunderstood how age verification works.”

Representing website operators who were among the plaintiffs who originally sued for the injunction, attorney Derek Shaffer cited Supreme Court precedent that he said “established that HB 1181 is subject to strict scrutiny,” Courthouse News Reported, adding that the strict scrutiny standard applies in cases where “laws infringe on fundamental rights and requires legislation to be narrowly tailored and the least restrictive means to further a compelling government interest.”

Shaffer also appealed to the standard that struck down the Child Online Protection Act of 1998. In that case, Courthouse News reported, the U.S. Supreme Court “specifically named content filtering as a least restrictive alternative to the anti-obscenity measures and noted that Texas lawmakers had provided no explanation as to why they had considered filtering and found it wanting.”

Content filtering, Shaffer added, “puts the responsibility where it should be, in the home and on parents.”

The three U.S. Circuit judges — George W. Bush appointee Jennifer Walker Elrod, and Ronald Reagan appointees Jerry Smith and Patrick Higginbotham — did not say when they would rule on Texas’ appeal.

FSC Executive Director Alison Boden told XBIZ, “We are optimistic that the 5th Circuit will uphold the district court judge’s well-reasoned ruling that HB 1181 is unconstitutional and should be prevented from going into effect in Texas.”

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Sara Jay, Dan Leal to Sponsor XBIZ Amsterdam Kick-Off Event

Sara Jay’s Wyde Syde Productions and Porno Dan Leal’s Market64 will co-sponsor the Bottoms Up Day Drinking kick-off event for XBIZ Amsterdam 2025 at Excalibur Café on Sept. 2, from 2-4 p.m. (CET).

AEBN Publishes Report on DP Trends

AEBN has published a report on DP and extreme penetration categories from its straight and gay theaters.

Free Speech Coalition Appoints Megan Stokes to Board of Directors

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) announced today that it has appointed Megan Stokes to its Board of Directors.

FansRevenue Acquires DivaTraffic

FansRevenue has acquired web traffic service DivaTraffic.

AEBN Announces Peter Green as Top Male Boy/Girl Performer for Summer 2025

AEBN has revealed its top 10 male Boy/Girl performers for summer 2025, with Peter Green landing atop the leaderboard.

Spicey AI Relaunches Site, Debuts $Spicey Tokens

Interactive voice chat platform Spicey AI has relaunched its website and introduced $Spicey tokens.

FSC: Missouri Age Verification Rule Will Not Take Effect August 30

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) announced that Missouri's proposed age verification legislation will not take effect on August 30, as it had originally estimated.

Little Caprice, Marcello Bravo to Co-Host 2025 XMA Europa Awards

XBIZ is pleased to announce that husband-and-wife duo Little Caprice and Marcello Bravo will co-host adult’s biggest night in Europe: the 2025 XMA Europa Awards on Sept. 4, in the epic climax to XBIZ’s fall events series.

Germany Will Block Payments to AV-Noncompliant Adult Sites as of Dec. 1

Starting Dec. 1, Germany will implement new rules prohibiting financial institutions from providing payment services to adult sites deemed to have inadequate age verification systems and making it easier for the government to target websites mirroring the content of such sites.

Jerkmate Joins Pineapple Support as Partner-Level Sponsor

Jerkmate has joined the ranks of over 70 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to Pineapple Support.

Show More