Leading Conservative Think Tank Slams 5th Circuit for Upholding Texas Age Verification Law

Leading Conservative Think Tank Slams 5th Circuit for Upholding Texas Age Verification Law

WASHINGTON — Leading conservative think tank the American Enterprise Institute has published an opinion piece penned by one of its senior fellows criticizing the 5th Circuit endorsement of Texas’ controversial age verification law.

The piece, written by Daniel Lyons and published Friday as part of the institute’s AEIdeas series, concludes that the 5th Circuit judges’ ideological hostility toward adult content has led them to “undermine basic rule of law principles in pursuit of their preferred policy objectives.”

“Because online activity is inherently communicative, the regulation of online expression is often complicated by the First Amendment,” Lyons writes. “But this is apparently not a problem that troubles the Fifth Circuit. In Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, the circuit court upheld a Texas law requiring pornographic websites to verify the age of their visitors — in the process dismissing two Supreme Court decisions finding such laws unconstitutional and consciously ignoring the difference between the offline world and cyberspace.”

Lyons points out that to most internet law scholars, it is obvious why previous age verification statutes have been enjoined by courts.

“Over two decades ago, at the dawn of the Internet age, a pair of Supreme Court cases, Reno v. ACLU and Ashcroft v. ACLU, struck down similar efforts by Congress to mandate age verification by pornographic websites,” he explains. “Although minors can generally be prohibited from accessing sexual material, adults have a First Amendment right to consume non-obscene pornography. Because age verification threatened to chill speech for adults, the Court applied strict scrutiny, and struck down both statutes because it found age verification was not the least restrictive means of limiting minors’ access without harming adults’ speech rights.”

To Lyons, the 5th Circuit’s conclusion that the U.S. Supreme Court struck down two federal statutes because the parties assumed the wrong standard of review, and that 25 years of internet law precedent based on those decisions failed to catch the error, is “laughable.”

Appellate judges, the opinion piece concludes, “cannot solve social problems by ignoring Supreme Court precedent with which they disagree. The Ninth Circuit gained a poor reputation for doing so regarding death penalty cases toward the end of the twentieth century, and the Fifth Circuit sadly seems to be following in its footsteps today.

“Once upon a time, conservatives decried such shenanigans as judicial activism.”

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

NYU Study Finds Age Verification Laws Don't Work

A group of university researchers has published a study whose findings suggest that age verification laws are ineffective at achieving their stated goal of preventing minors from accessing adult content.

XVideos Loses Advertiser Reporting Appeal in EU Court

Web Group Czech Republic (WGCZ), parent company of XVideos, has lost an appeal in the top EU court to be temporarily exempted from a requirement to publish a list of the site's advertisers.

2025 Pornhub Awards to Be Held May 8 in Los Angeles

The seventh annual Pornhub Awards will take place May 8 in Los Angeles.

Illinois Lawmakers Propose Decriminalizing Consensual Sex Work

Lawmakers in Illinois have introduced a bill that would completely decriminalize consensual sex work in the state.

VR Bangers Joins Pineapple Support as Supporter-Level Sponsor

VR Bangers has joined the ranks of over 60 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to Pineapple Support.

Missouri House Gives Initial Approval to Age Verification Bill

The Missouri House of Representatives has given initial approval to HB 236, the state's proposed age verification law.

Proposed Australian eSafety Codes Include AV Requirement for Adult Sites

Australia’s online safety regulator, eSafety, is reviewing the final draft of proposed safety codes that include a requirement for adult sites to implement age assurance measures for Australian users.

Pineapple Support to Host 'Self-Harm' Support Group

Pineapple Support is hosting a free online support group for performers and creators who engage in self-harming behaviors.

Ofcom Q&A: Preparing for Age Verification Under the UK's Online Safety Act

In January, the U.K.’s online safety regulator, Ofcom, published its guidance on how online services that host adult content need to verify users’ ages under Ofcom’s rules.

Pineapple Support Taps Reagan Foxx as Brand Ambassador

Pineapple Support has named Reagan Foxx as its newest brand ambassador.

Show More