Supreme Court Hears Pivotal Texas AV Case

Supreme Court Hears Pivotal Texas AV Case

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday heard oral arguments in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, the case challenging Texas’ controversial age verification law, HB 1181.

HB 1181 was passed by the Texas legislature in May 2023 and is a much-augmented version of Louisiana’s age verification law and its many copycat versions in other states. At the time, FSC condemned the law as “blatantly unconstitutional” and a “violation of the First Amendment rights of creators, consumers and platforms.”

The issue before the court is what standard of review should apply to such a law, which aims to protect minors but in the process burdens adults’ access to protected speech. A lower court applied only the “rational basis” standard, whereas FSC, its fellow plaintiffs and free speech advocates maintain that the highest level of judicial review, “strict scrutiny,” must apply.

In a September 2024 statement, FSC argued, “Where a less-restrictive alternative exists — for example, the voluntary installation of filtering software on minors’ devices — the government cannot impose age verification on adults in the name of protecting children.”

According to court transcripts, Justice Sonia Sotomayor noted during oral arguments that the court has previously, on at least five occasions, applied the highest level of legal scrutiny when deciding similar cases.

“For us to apply anything else would be overturning at least five precedents,” she said.

Justice Elena Kagan cited “possible spillover dangers.”

“You relax strict scrutiny in one place and all of a sudden strict scrutiny gets relaxed in other places,” she said. “You treat a clearly content-based law as not requiring strict scrutiny and all of a sudden you start seeing more content-based restrictions that don’t have to satisfy strict scrutiny.”

The court’s conservative justices, by contrast, seemed to suggest that advances in technology have rendered past standards obsolete.

Conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett cited the ease with which minors can access adult content online and questioned the efficacy of content filtering across various devices.

“I think that the explosion of addiction in — to online porn has shown that content filtering isn’t working,” she said.

Chief Justice John Roberts opined that “the nature of the pornography” has changed.

“Are those the sort of developments that suggest revisiting the standard of scrutiny as — as something that we should at least consider, as opposed to keeping a structure that was accepted and established in an entirely different era?” he asked.

Derek Shaffer of Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, who argued on behalf of FSC and the other plaintiffs, urged the court to follow precedent.

“The tradition on the internet is to say that it will be free and that it is incumbent upon parents to screen out content that is inappropriate for their kids,” he told the justices. “That's where the law should stay.”

Electronic Frontier Foundation Staff Attorney Lisa Femia, who attended the arguments in person, said in a statement, “Nothing in the argument today changed the fact that Texas' age-verification law places immense burdens on adults' First Amendment rights, and we urge the Supreme Court to overturn the Fifth Circuit's decision upholding the law.

“The Texas law robs adult internet users of anonymity, exposes them to serious privacy and security risks, and blocks some adults entirely from accessing sexual content that’s protected under the First Amendment,” she added. “Texas completely failed to appreciate the substantial privacy and security risks at issue, and continued to incorrectly suggest that online age verification – which requires millions of internet users to upload and submit identifying information – is no different than quick, one-on-one, in-person ID checks. Other courts have consistently held that similar online age verification laws are unconstitutional. To protect freedom of speech online, the Supreme Court should clearly reaffirm those correct decisions here.”

The court's decision is expected sometime over the next several months. The court could rule directly on the constitutionality of the Texas law, or it could send the case back to a lower court with instructions as to what level of scrutiny to apply.

Either way, the court’s eventual ruling in the case is expected to impact state age verification laws around the country and other litigation.

In July 2024, a Texas district judge granted a request by Pornhub parent company Aylo to pause proceedings in a lawsuit filed by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton over Pornhub’s alleged failure to implement age verification requirements, pending the Supreme Court's ruling in FSC v. Paxton. In December, a U.S. district court judge paused a lawsuit over Indiana’s age verification law, and Florida’s attorney general asked a federal court to halt the FSC lawsuit challenging that state's AV law, until the court decides the Texas case.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Sara Jay, Dan Leal to Sponsor XBIZ Amsterdam Kick-Off Event

Sara Jay’s Wyde Syde Productions and Porno Dan Leal’s Market64 will co-sponsor the Bottoms Up Day Drinking kick-off event for XBIZ Amsterdam 2025 at Excalibur Café on Sept. 2, from 2-4 p.m. (CET).

AEBN Publishes Report on DP Trends

AEBN has published a report on DP and extreme penetration categories from its straight and gay theaters.

Free Speech Coalition Appoints Megan Stokes to Board of Directors

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) announced today that it has appointed Megan Stokes to its Board of Directors.

FansRevenue Acquires DivaTraffic

FansRevenue has acquired web traffic service DivaTraffic.

AEBN Announces Peter Green as Top Male Boy/Girl Performer for Summer 2025

AEBN has revealed its top 10 male Boy/Girl performers for summer 2025, with Peter Green landing atop the leaderboard.

Spicey AI Relaunches Site, Debuts $Spicey Tokens

Interactive voice chat platform Spicey AI has relaunched its website and introduced $Spicey tokens.

FSC: Missouri Age Verification Rule Will Not Take Effect August 30

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) announced that Missouri's proposed age verification legislation will not take effect on August 30, as it had originally estimated.

Little Caprice, Marcello Bravo to Co-Host 2025 XMA Europa Awards

XBIZ is pleased to announce that husband-and-wife duo Little Caprice and Marcello Bravo will co-host adult’s biggest night in Europe: the 2025 XMA Europa Awards on Sept. 4, in the epic climax to XBIZ’s fall events series.

Germany Will Block Payments to AV-Noncompliant Adult Sites as of Dec. 1

Starting Dec. 1, Germany will implement new rules prohibiting financial institutions from providing payment services to adult sites deemed to have inadequate age verification systems and making it easier for the government to target websites mirroring the content of such sites.

Jerkmate Joins Pineapple Support as Partner-Level Sponsor

Jerkmate has joined the ranks of over 70 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to Pineapple Support.

Show More