Arkansas 'Harmful to Minors' Law Declared Unconstitutional

LITTLE ROCK, Ark. — A federal judge struck down a state law Wednesday that barred any public venue from shelving material that could be considered “harmful to minors,” declaring the law overbroad and a form of unconstitutional prior restraint.

The ruling, which was an important victory for adult stores as well as mainstream bookstores that stock items that may contain sexually oriented passages, said that Arkansas’s Act 858 violated both the First and Fourteenth Amendments.

The act, set to go into effect at the end of June 2003, amended state law to “require material harmful to minors to be obstructed from view and segregated in commercial establishments and for other purposes.”

While the original code only required venues that stocked material deemed “harmful to minors” in racks with opaque covers that obscured their view, the amended law required complete segregation of materials that may contain “harmful” passages, even if their covers or bindings were not expressly so.

The coalition of plaintiffs in the lawsuit, including members of the Arkansas Library Association, the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund and the American Civil Liberties Union, alleged that the law would require them to have an impossible knowledge of each item in the store and spend money building expensive partitions or face closing their doors to people under the age of 18.

“Libraries have been challenged in the past for circulating classic works by authors like Judy Blume, John Steinbeck and J.D. Salinger,” Arkansas Library Association President Dwain Gordon told the court. “I [also] understand that material depicting one or more nude female breasts can be considered ‘harmful to minors’ under the Arkansas law.”

“While none of these titles are generally shelved in children’s sections, if I understand the law correctly, ALA members will violate the law if they shelve these books in areas that minors could access,” said Gordon. “One might even worry that librarians will have to remove or restrict access to the nude statue of Icarus and Daedalus that decorates the main branch of the [Central Arkansas Library System].”

According to both U.S. District Court Judge G. Thomas Eisele, Arkansas’ new code would be overbroad because it not only linked the acts of displaying material, a “mass act” which could merely include having it on a shelf, and actually selling it, which involves a single, one-on-one interaction.

The Arkansas Supreme Court, in answer to several questions made by Eisele, also found problems with the law’s assumption that material that would be inappropriate for a 5-year-old would also be inappropriate for a 17-year-old.

“If the younger minors are to be protected from ‘harmful’ materials, surely the General Assembly did not intend for those younger children to be permitted to access materials that would arguably be ‘harmful’ to them, even though not ‘harmful’ to an older child,” wrote Supreme Court Associate Justice Tom Glaze in its majority opinion. “We cannot construe Arkansas’ statutory law in such a way as to render it meaningless, and we will not interpret a statute to yield absurd results that are contrary to legislative intent.”

Spokespeople for the Arkansas Attorney General’s office told media Wednesday that the ruling should not be heralded as a huge victory.

“It will be up to the individual prosecutors as to how they choose to enforce the law,” Matt DeCample told the Arkansas Democrat Gazette, noting that when one clause of a law is struck down, the other clauses are usually still enforceable.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Fleshy to Launch Interactive Cam Site 'Eremote'

Male pleasure brand Fleshy has announced that it will launch an interactive, bidirectional cam site next month called Eremote.

New York Magazine Names 'Magic Wand Rechargeable' Its 'Best Overall Vibrator'

New York Magazine's "The Strategist" vertical has named Vibratex's Magic Wand Rechargeable the best overall vibrator.

Global Novelties Debuts New 'Stoner Vibes' Collection

Global Novelties has introduced its new Stoner Vibes in the Rear collection.

2025 XBIZ Exec Awards Nominees for Retail Industry Announced

XBIZ is pleased to announce the nominees for the retail industry edition of the 2025 XBIZ Exec Awards, set to be presented as part of the annual XBIZ Honors ceremony on Saturday, Jan. 18 in conjunction with XBIZ Expo.

Project 2025 Leader Claims Big Tech Companies 'Deliberately Fuel Pornography Addiction' Among Men

Heritage Foundation president and Project 2025 leader Kevin Roberts published on Wednesday the text of a speech in which he persists with his past claim that “predatory Big Tech corporations” are “deliberately fueling pornography addiction” among young men.

FSC Petitions 10th Circuit for Review of Utah AV Dismissal

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) on Wednesday petitioned the United States Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit to review a decision handed down earlier this month by a three-judge panel of the same appeals court, which denied FSC the right to challenge Utah’s controversial age verification law by suing state officials.

MyAdultAttorney's Corey D. Silverstein to Hold Post-Election Legal Impact Webinar

Industry attorney Corey D. Silverstein will hold a “Legal Impact” webinar titled “We Have a New U.S. President: Legal and Community Implications” on Nov. 12 at 1 p.m. PST.

JO to Hold Retail Associate Giveaway Throughout 2025

Lubricant brand JO has announced plans to conduct a retail associate giveaway each month throughout 2025.

Pornhub Shuts Down Access in Oklahoma Over Age Verification

Aylo began geo-blocking Pornhub across Oklahoma on Tuesday, three days in advance of the state’s new age verification law, SB 1959, taking effect.

Honey Play Box Sponsors La Faye Rose 'Pink October' Fundraiser

Honey Play Box sponsored La Faye Rose’s annual Pink October breast cancer fundraiser event, on Oct. 13.

Show More