Analyst: MPAA Is Winning the War Against File-Sharing

CYBERSPACE — The assault on file sharing may be yielding big dividends for the Motion Picture Association of America.

Since the advent of file-sharing communities and networks like LimeWire and BitTorrent, the MPAA has been filing one lawsuit after another in an effort to stop consumers from downloading and sharing free versions of popular, first-run TV shows and movies.

According to Wired, four bit-torrent-related websites have shut down since March.

Wired's David Kravets argues that the MPAA is winning in the war against file sharing, though he added that a central legal argument is still hanging in the air.

"Unanswered is the central legal question of whether such sites violate U.S. copyright law for pointing to where users can download copyrighted works from others," he said.

TorrentSpy lawyer Ira Rothken agreed. In May, A federal judge in California ordered TorrentSpy to pay a $111 million penalty for its role in distributing copyrighted works. Rothken called the ruling a "Hollywood publicity stunt," arguing that it was not decided on the merits of copyright law.

Nevertheless, even in the adult industry, the fight against file sharing and video sharing continues. Last December, Vivid sued PornoTube's parent company, AEBN, for copyright infringement. Adult director Eli Cross told XBIZ that the industry is moving into an era where everyone expects content to be free. All Media Play President Jeff Mullen agreed.

"We really need to take [content theft] seriously," Mullen told XBIZ. "Everyone thinks 2257 is the biggest problem, but we need to stop the outright theft that's going on."

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

On-Chain JAV Distribution Platform 'HandSome' Goes Live With Open Beta

Fukuoka tech firm Fidem has officially rolled out an open beta version of HandSome, a new Japanese Adult Video (JAV) content distribution platform built on blockchain technology.

Arcom Investigates Mym Over SREN Compliance

French media regulator Arcom is investigating creator platform Mym to determine whether the site may have violated age assurance rules and/or other requirements of France’s Security and Regulation of the Digital Space (SREN) law.

England, Wales to Enforce 'Extreme' Content Laws Starting Nov. 6

England and Wales will begin enforcing new laws criminalizing depictions of “non-fatal strangulation,” as well as sexual content in which adults portray underage characters, starting Nov. 6, the U.K. Ministry of Justice announced Friday.

Report: UK Film Classification Board to Monitor 'Extreme' Content Online

The U.K. government has tapped the British Board of Film Classification (BBFC) for a pilot program to monitor online pornography for illegal and “extreme” content, as it prepares to enforce new content restrictions, British media outlet Sky News is reporting.

New Federal Report Slams Debanking but Ignores Adult Industry

The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) on Wednesday released a report on debanking activities at nine large national banks, but omitted any mention of the adult industry, despite previously identifying it as a sector facing banking discrimination.

EU Court Rejects Stripchat Challenge of Past VLOP Designation

The EU’s General Court on Wednesday ruled against Stripchat in a lawsuit seeking to annul a 2023 European Commission decision designating the site as a “very large online platform” (VLOP) under the Digital Services Act (DSA).

Aylo Case Against Utah VPN Rule on Hold Pending Legislative Changes

A federal court has paused Aylo’s suit over a Utah law making adult websites liable if minors bypass age verification by circumventing geolocation efforts, until the state legislature can meets to potentially amend the statute.

German High Court Puts Pornhub, YouPorn 'Network Ban' on Hold

A German high court on Friday temporarily barred a state media regulator from ordering internet providers to cut off access to Aylo-owned adult sites Pornhub and YouPorn in Germany, pending further action by Cypriot and European Union authorities.

Luxembourg Media Regulator Fines LiveJasmin for AV Noncompliance

The Luxembourg Independent Audiovisual Authority (ALIA) has levied a fine of 25,000 euros (approximately $28,000) against webcam platform LiveJasmin for failing to comply with provisions of the country’s Electronic Media Law.

AdultHTML Introduces Subscription Option for Website Owners

AdultHTML has added a subscription option for its web development service, allowing site owners to pay a monthly fee for access to developers and tools.

Show More