TorrentSpy Lawyer Responds to $111M Penalty

LOS ANGELES — Calling the ruling a "Hollywood publicity stunt," TorrentSpy lawyer Ira Rothken said that yesterday's $111 million judgment against the torrent-tracking service TorrentSpy was not decided on the merits of copyright law.

Yesterday, U.S. District Judge Florence-Marie Cooper hit TorrentSpy for $30,000 for each of 3,699 counts of copyright infringement brought against the company by the Motion Picture Association of America.

As for the $111 million penalty, Rothken said that although TorrentSpy's parent company, Valence Media, "will obey the law," he noted that the company filed for bankruptcy protection in England last week.

"[They have] no appreciable assets," he said. "This was a Hollywood publicity stunt."

MPAA Communications Director Elizabeth Kaltman told XBIZ that Judge Cooper's decision "speaks for itself," and that despite Valence Media's bankruptcy filing, the MPAA plans to "pursue enforcement of the judgment."

In March, TorrentSpy lost the case on a default judgment. Judge Cooper said that the company had destroyed evidence and provided false testimony during the discovery process for their trial with the MPAA. Kaltman said that this decision "clearly indicates that there was some wrongdoing that [TorrentSpy was] trying to cover up."

But Rothken contended that TorrentSpy had only been protecting its users' privacy.

"One man's alleged evidence destruction is another man's privacy protection," he said.

Adult industry attorney Rob Apgood told XBIZ he applauded the decision.

"Copyright infringement is so rampant on the Internet, and it's severely damaging copyright holders," said Apgood, a member of the firm CarpeLaw. "People who facilitate theft should be held just as accountable as the thieves themselves."

Online guru Brandon Shalton agreed with Apgood's assessment, even though TorrentSpy, by its very nature, hosts no copyrighted content on its servers, a distinction Rothken made.

TorrentSpy works like a search engine, except that it seeks out small text files, often called "torrent files," that users then load into locally hosted proprietary programs that use the files as guideposts to find and download actual media files.

Rothken pointed out that Google could be used for the same purpose — a simple search for torrent files for the TV show "Lost" returned more than 200,000 results — but Shalton said that sites like TorrentSpy are "essentially an accessory" because they only search for torrent files.

"When you look at the content on torrent sites, probably like 99 percent of it is stolen," said Shalton, who founded the traffic analysis service T3Report.com. "Anyone who sets up a torrent website knows it's illegal stuff. So that’s the gray area. If you know that what it has is mostly illegal, then you know what's up."

Rothken has appealed the case to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco.

Related:  

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Clip Page Launches 'Creator Analytics' Feature

Custom content marketplace Clip Page has launched the Creator Analytics feature on its platform.

BBWXXXAdventures Relaunches Through Grooby's Blue.xxx

Paysite BBWXXXAdventures has relaunched under Grooby's new website management company Blue.xxx.

Flirt4Free Announces 'Tease the Season' Holiday Contest

Flirt4Free has announced its Tease the Season promo and model contest, which will run Dec. 21-25.The competition is led by the return of the Snowflake Contest, where models can be gifted digital snowflakes by their fans. The models who collect the most snowflakes by 11:59 a.m. on Christmas Day will win cash prizes.

SWR Data Publishes 2024 'Top Creator Platforms' Report

Adult industry market research firm SWR Data has published a report on the Top Creator Platforms of 2024.

MintStars Joins Pineapple Support as Supporter-Level Sponsor

Content platform MintStars has joined the ranks of over 60 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to Pineapple Support.

Politicians Aim to Study Effects of FOSTA-SESTA on Sex Workers

In an encouraging sign for sex workers, California State Representative Ro Khanna and U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts have reintroduced the SAFE SEX Workers Study Act, which aims to study the effects of FOSTA-SESTA.

Pornhub to Shut Down Access in Florida Over Age Verification

Aylo will geoblock Pornhub across Florida starting Jan. 1, when HB 3, the state's age verification law, goes into effect.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches by Country for October, November

AEBN has released the list of popular searches from its straight and gay theaters by country in October and November.

Jacquie et Michel Acquired by 'International Fund'

French adult studio Jacquie et Michel has been acquired by an international fund, marking a significant development for the well-known brand.

YouPay Joins Pineapple Support as Sponsor, Introduces 'Permanent Donation' Feature

Australian gifting platform YouPay has joined the ranks of Pineapple Support’s partner-level sponsors.

Show More