opinion

Flirting With the FBI

Something happened a few months ago that was reported in the adult media but which caused barely a ripple in the industry, and you really have to ask yourself why there was no outcry about it on the boards, and no phone calls or emails into the office asking for clarification or follow-up information.

That something was a "secret" meeting in Washington between seven adult companies and the FBI. The subject under discussion was 18 U.S.C. § 2257, the notorious federal labeling and record-keeping regulations that continue to haunt the industry, and purposelessly so.

Actually, I knew about the meeting in advance and even saw a copy of the letter sent by the FBI to one of the seven companies, but the name of the company in question was redacted. The gist of the letter was that the FBI wanted to talk about the 2257 inspections process, but it was unclear what they wanted to discuss or why they invited the particular companies. There was, as I recall, a reference to "leaders in the industry."

What struck me about the letter was the fact that no confidentiality was requested, which one would certainly expect the FBI to request unless they wanted the fact of the meeting — and what happened at the meeting — to go out to the adult industry. I planned on writing about the upcoming meeting, but was asked — no, implored — by an industry attorney not to write about it beforehand, and to drive the point home he told me that I would do "inestimable damage" if I did. I wrote and said nothing, but I did stay in close contact with the attorney up to the date of the meeting, attempted independent contact with the coordinating FBI agent (to no avail), and received a guarantee by another lawyer who was going to be in attendance that coverage would be provided us.

It was and it wasn't. Adult media got a story to post afterwards, but we could have written the copy ourselves without even having been there! No details were forthcoming, and certainly no specifics as to what the FBI said or what was said to the FBI. At the time, it made me wonder what the point was.

As a result, I was in this column going to excoriate those in attendance for staying so mum, but then Greg Piccionelli sent in his column, which will appear here tomorrow, in which he provides a great deal of detail about the meeting, much of it very interesting but some of it confusing.

He says, for instance, that the supervising agent called the meeting in part because of "concern about a number of adult media industry stories that were inaccurately reporting information regarding the inspection process." This is a particularly interesting comment considering the fact that in the process of writing coverage of each of the inspections XBIZ writers placed calls to the FBI for comment and to fact check. Unfortunately, all they were ever told is that inspections took place.

So the FBI can hardly complain about the results of adult media coverage if they decline to comment for that coverage. Piccionelli also states that at the end of the meeting the supervising agent "reiterated his sincere desire to establish a dialogue with the industry," and seemed enthusiastic about the prospect of communicating directly with adult media companies.

I hope so. We have calls in. We are waiting to hear back.

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

profile

Chaturbate's Emely Zuniga Talks Show Floor Magic and Creator Care

During industry events, you’ll likely find Zuniga gliding through the room, greeting creators, checking details and making sure everyone around her feels taken care of. With her colorful red hair, perfectly done nails and an easygoing, “work bestie” demeanor that instantly puts people at ease, she thrives in the fast-paced environment of conferences and trade shows.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

What to Know About Deepfakes, Likeness Rights, and Digital Consent

AI is reshaping virtually every sector of the global economy, and the adult industry is no exception. Many adult companies have already explored or adopted AI in content production, and surveys indicate that around 65% have considered implementing AI technologies in their operations.

Christoph Hermes ·
opinion

Key Strategies for Adapting to Stricter PCI Compliance Standards

When it comes to PCI compliance, the days of simply filling out some paperwork and answering a few questions are gone. A casual approach is just not viable anymore.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

How to Maximize Value From Your Payment Processing Fees

Regulatory requirements are putting more and more pressure on the adult industry. To stay compliant, merchants need tools that help with content moderation, age verification and fraud solutions. Unfortunately, the fees for those tools are hitting merchants’ bottom lines — including fees charged by payment services providers.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Understanding Sin Taxes and the Legal Roadblocks Ahead

As of this writing, a bill sits on the desk of Utah’s governor, awaiting his signature to make it state law. That bill includes a provision imposing an excise tax of 2% on adult sites operating in the state.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
profile

LoyalFans' Anastasia Pierce Bridges Creator Education, Empowerment and Ownership

Anastasia Pierce beams when she talks about her 26 years in the industry. Full of passionate energy, she clearly doesn’t just work in adult; she loves it.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

Growing Site Revenue Under Ever-Changing Compliance Rules

Over the past year, many merchants have reported earnings that were flat or even a bit down. This is due to three main factors: age verification regulations, click-to-cancel rules, and banks backing away from cross-sales due to regulatory requirements and the rollout of the Visa Acquiring Monitoring Program (VAMP).

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

AI Safeguards for Platform Compliance and Trust

If your platform hosts user-generated content (UGC), then you already know protecting your brand is not merely a matter of good design or strong community guidelines. It requires systems that can verify who your users are, filter what they upload and ensure your business stays on the right side of regulators, payment processors and public opinion.

Christoph Hermes ·
opinion

How to Eliminate User Redirects and Improve Checkout Retention

Running an adult site, you work hard to create traffic and make sure your funnel is optimal, with the end goal of getting users to make a purchase. Then, right at that critical moment, what do you do? You send them somewhere else. Not good.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

Stripchat's Jessica on Building Creator Success, One Step at a Time

At most industry events, the spotlight naturally falls on the creators whose personalities light up screens and social feeds. Behind the booths, parties and perfectly timed photo ops, however, there is someone else shaping the experience.

Jackie Backman ·
Show More