opinion

Dissecting an $11.9M Affiliate Marketing Judgment

The Federal Trade Commission scored another major win in early October when the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a lower court ruling, requiring LeadClick Media LLC to pay an $11.9 million award.

The 2nd Circuit includes the states of Connecticut, New York and Vermont, where it has appellate jurisdiction.

For the countless affiliate networks that incorrectly believe that affiliate networks cannot be found liable by the FTC for the acts of their affiliates, think again.

The FTC released its own press release on Oct. 4 calling the 2nd Circuit’s decision a “victory for consumers.”

This case began in 2011 when the FTC and the state of Connecticut chose to pursue LeanSpa and its principal Boris Mizhen. The defendants were accused of utilizing fake news websites to promote their own products, make deceptive weight-loss claims and were also accused of misrepresenting the costs associated with “free” trials.

In July 2014, the FTC announced that it had reached a resolution with LeanSpa and Mizhen.

On Aug 28, 2013, the FTC and the state of Connecticut filed its third amended complaint for preliminary injunction and other equitable relief. The third amended complaint added claims against LeadClick and CareLogic Inc. (the parent company of LeadClick). It is alleged that LeadClick was an “affiliate marketing network operator for LeadSpace.”

The plaintiffs alleged that “LeadClick’s network lured consumers to LeanSpa’s online store through fake news websites designed to trick consumers into believing that real, independent news outlets and genuine customers, rather than paid advertisers and actors, had reviewed and endorsed LeanSpa’s products.”

In the early part of 2015, the U.S. District Court in Connecticut granted the FTC’s request for summary judgment. Amongst other things, the court found that LeadClick was responsible for the false claims made by affiliate marketers it recruited on behalf of LeanSpa.

The district court, in finding LeadClick responsible for the deceptive content on its affiliates’ websites, noted that LeadClick recruited the affiliates, had power to approve or reject their marketing websites, paid the affiliates, purchased advertising space for them and gave them feedback about the content of their sites.

It is essential to note that LeadClick attempted to defend itself by claiming immunity under 47 U.S.C. § 230 of the Communications Decency Act but the court rejected that defense. The 2nd Circuit agreed with the lower court and found Section 230 inapplicable because LeadClick participated in the development of the deceptive content.

For those of you unfamiliar with Section 230 of the CDA, now is a great time to read up. Section 230 is arguably one of the most important laws that all e-commerce operators should be deeply familiar with.

Section 230 explicitly states, “No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information provider.”

Section 230 gives interactive online services of all types broad immunity from certain types of legal liability stemming from content created by others.

News sites, chat blogs, public forums and tube sites have all utilized Section 230 in one way or another. A common misunderstanding about Section 230 is that the statute provides complete protection. That is simply not the case. Federal criminal liability and intellectual property claims are exempt from Section 230 protection.

This case presents an amazing learning opportunity for e-commerce websites (including adult industry businesses) to stay away from specific activities that can get you into the cross-hairs of the FTC. This case is yet another example of the strength, persistence and tenacity of the FTC and the 2nd Circuit has confirmed the inapplicability of Section 230 when a party seeking Section 230 immunity is found to have participated in the unlawful act. It is noteworthy that a pattern has been developing throughout the U.S. where Section 230 is becoming more difficult to utilize.

This situation also presents a window for affiliate networks, affiliate programs and individual affiliates to carefully review their services and practices and ensure that they are not running afoul with the law. Most notably that they are not engaging in deceptive trade practices or otherwise violating the law. Affiliate networks and programs need to consult with attorneys familiar with FTC regulations so that they can evaluate whether they may be engaging in conduct that goes too far and could subject them to liability for actions related to the products and services that they are promoting.

For the countless affiliate networks that incorrectly believe that affiliate networks cannot be found liable by the FTC for the acts of their affiliates, think again. LeadClick Media’s misfortune presents a learning opportunity for everyone else and it would be a shame if people didn’t learn from the mistakes of others.

Corey D. Silverstein is the managing and founding member of the Law Offices of Corey D. Silverstein P.C., which focuses on representing all areas of the adult industry and his clientele includes hosting companies, affiliate programs, content producers, processing companies, website owners and performers, just to name a few. His websites include MyAdultAttorney.com and Porn.law. Silverstein can be reached by email at corey@myadultattorney.com; his site, MyAdultAttorney.com; or by telephone at (248) 290-0655

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

The SCREEN Test: How to Prepare for Federal Age Verification

For those who are counting, there are now 20 enacted state laws in the United States requiring age verification for viewing online adult content, plus numerous proposed laws in the works. This ongoing barrage has been exhausting for many in the adult industry — and it may be about to escalate in the form of a potential new AV law, this time at the federal level.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

How to Master Team Dynamics for Business Success

Having the right team in place is everything. Whether getting a startup off the ground and thriving, or safeguarding an established company, the right — or wrong — people can mean the difference between a successful venture and a failed dream.

Juicy Jay ·
opinion

Eight Steps to Fast-Track AI Site Approval for Processing

Artificial intelligence is a hot topic these days. AI technology is speeding up the way we do business across all industries and offers numerous benefits, from automating processes to increasing efficiency and scalability.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

How to Secure High-Risk Transactions With Network Tokenization

Ensuring the security of data as it moves through digital channels is the foundation of safe transactions, and crucial for your success. If your business can’t secure transactions, you’re exposed to myriad processing traumas.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

WIA Profile: Reba Rocket

As chief operating officer and chief marketing officer of Takedown Piracy, long at the forefront of intellectual property protection in adult entertainment, Rocket is dedicated to safeguarding the livelihoods of content creators and producers while fostering a more ethical and sustainable industry.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

Protecting Content Ownership Rights When Using AI

In today’s digital age, content producers have more tools at their disposal than ever before. Among these tools, artificial intelligence (AI) content generation has emerged as a game changer, enabling creators to produce high-quality content quickly and efficiently.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

How Payment Orchestration Can Help Your Business

An emerging payment solution is making waves in the merchant world: the payment orchestration platform (POP). It’s quickly gaining traction as a powerful tool for managing online payments — but questions abound.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Fine-Tuning Refund and Cancellation Policies

For adult websites, managing refunds and cancellations isn’t just about customer service. It’s a crucial factor in maintaining compliance with the regulations of payment processors and payment networks such as Visa and Mastercard.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

WIA Profile: Laurel Bencomo

Born in Cambridge, England but raised in Spain, Laurel Bencomo initially chose to study business at the University of Barcelona simply because it felt familiar — both of her parents are entrepreneurs. She went on to earn a master’s degree in sales and marketing management at the EADA Business School, while working in events for a group of restaurants in Barcelona.

Women In Adult ·
profile

Gregory Dorcel on Building Upon His Brand's Signature Legacy

“Whether reflected in the storyline or the cast or even the locations, the entertainment we deliver is based on fantasy,” he elaborates. “Our business is not, and never has been, reality. People who are buying our content aren’t expecting reality, or direct contact with stars like you can have with OnlyFans,” he says.

Jeff Dana ·
Show More