educational

Trouble in Toyland

The sex toy industry has been caught up in a flurry of lawsuits lately, at the heart of which is ownership, control and presentation of the Adult Novelty Manufacturers Expo, which has been a yearly flagship event for sex toy manufacturers.

Sex toy makers California Exotic Novelties, Doc Johnson, TopCo Sales and Nass Toys filed a trademark infringement lawsuit in federal court in November against Kammo Productions and the firm's president, Nick Orlandino, according to legal documents obtained by XBiz and confirmed by attorney Mark Hoffman of Labowe Labowe & Hoffman, who is representing the plaintiffs along with co-counsel from Lipsitz Green Fahringer Roll Salisbury & Cambria LLP.

Orlandino has filed a counterclaim in the Central District of California against the adult novelty companies in addition to a separate suit in Los Angeles Superior Court against AVN, which Orlandino claims is related to AVN's similarly named sex toy tradeshow called AVN Adult Novelty Expo (ANE).

The ANE debut show is slated for July, the same month as the next ANME show, and will be attended by California Exotic Novelties, Doc Johnson, TopCo Sales and Nass Toys, four companies that were formerly associated with ANME.

Orlandino claims that those four companies are rivaling Kammo's ANME, which is scheduled to take place at the Mandalay Bay Resort & Casino in Las Vegas from July 11-13. At one point, CalExotics even sought a preliminary injunction to prohibit Kammo from using the ANME name for its upcoming convention. But at a Feb. 9 hearing, the injunction was denied.

Suit Against AVN
According to court documents, Orlandino's lawsuit against AVN began with an article published on the company's website on Nov. 1 that said ANME would now be operated by AVN's Event Division. The article opened by announcing the new management of ANME and went on to state that the managerial change was because "differences with [Kammo] could not be resolved."

The lawsuit states that the article, which was taken down shortly after AVN was notified, was the first in a string of events designed to wrest control of the ANME event away from Kammo, including solicitations made to ANME vendors to attend the new show. The suit also alleges that AVN engaged in improperly using the ANME name to promote its own tradeshow.

"The defendants threaten to continue their efforts to publish and communicate false statements about [Kammo] and its business operations among vendors and retailers," the lawsuit reads. "Unless enjoined, the defendants will continue to do so and continue to cause [Kammo] great and irreparable injury."

But AVN's "Unverified Answer" legal documents filed in the suit paint a different picture. According to the document, filed on Dec. 23, AVN was operating under the assurances of other third parties that told AVN they owned the ANME name. The response also asserts that Kammo did not name the appropriate defendants in the suit, that Kammo did not own any type of valid service mark to the ANME and Adult Novelty Manufacturers Expo names, and that any damages claimed by Kammo were purely speculative and incapable of being proved.

AVN also points out in its response that Kammo's causes of actions violate the First Amendment rights of the defendants named in the suit.

Records obtained from the U.S. Patent and Trademark office make the picture murkier. Though documents are currently on file for both the Adult Novelty Manufacturers Expo and ANME, and their owner is listed as Kammo Productions Inc., the filing date on both applications is listed as Nov. 19, 2004, 18 days after AVN's article was published, 13 days after California Exotic Novelties filed suit against Kammo, and five days before Kammo filed its lawsuit against AVN.

In many ways, ANME may have become a victim of its own success. The growth of the convention triggered disagreements, and differences emerged among its leading participants over the future direction of the expo.

The industry-only convention began in 1996, and until this year, took place annually in July at the Sheraton Universal, near Universal Studios in Los Angeles.

"When I first attended ANME in the 1990s, it was one little room and it took me half an hour to walk through it," said David Levine, president of Sex-Toy.com, which sells adult novelties online. "All the distributors and manufacturers are there. You see the latest and greatest in new things. Now it's bigger and more successful than ever, to the point that they felt they needed a larger space, because there wasn't any room for more booths."

But following the July 2004 ANME, "The Sheraton Universal asked us not to come back, because the show got too big. We had people stuck in closets almost, and there were people running around half naked. Some crazy stuff went on," Orlandino said.

Squeezed In The Middle
Consequently, the legal squabble is causing fallout among many of the smaller sex toy businesses, which are being caught in the middle. Some feel that the organizers of the two events are toying with their affections.

Sadie Allison, the owner of TickleKitty.com, sells adult novelties manufactured by other companies and writes and self publishes how-to sex guidebooks.

"For us smaller manufacturers, we just want to go where the buyers are going and have one cohesive family," Allison told XBiz. "It's challenging for us, because we're trying to figure out which show to attend and where buyers will be going to look for products. I've spoken with peers in the business and many are up in the air about where to exhibit. We're just trying to do our thing. It puts a strain on everyone's business."

Like others in the adult novelty trade, the San Francisco-based businesswoman is now faced with the onerous prospect of having to travel to and participate in two separate conventions, only about a week apart from one another.

"That's not something I'm happy about, if that's what I end up doing," Allison said. "As a small business, sometimes we might not be able to afford that."

If asked to choose between the two tradeshows, Allison said, "At this time I'm undecided."

Levine felt similarly.

"I'm not picking any favorites," Levine said. "I love them all, and I carry all of their products. They're being all one show is easier for me. But if there's two shows, I'd probably go to both."

The dispute has caused confusion, Allison said.

"It's disappointing, too, Allison said. "The toy manufacturers' industry is not that huge. It's a little disheartening. It's one of those 'I wish we could all get along' things.'"

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

Why Inclusivity in the Pleasure Industry Is More Important Than Ever

2025 has kicked off with a series of unsettling events. Tension and anxiety are high across North America as the unknown impact of tariffs, climate change and attacks on human rights loom ominously. In times of unrest, seeking pleasure is not frivolity but necessity.

Sarah Tomchesson ·
opinion

Tips for Keeping the Adult Retail Trade Show Momentum Going

Trade shows are a whirlwind of energy, excitement and opportunities. You spend days on a vibrant, buzzing show floor, making valuable connections and discovering innovative and exciting new products. You spend time, energy and money to be a part of this fabulous circus.

Rin Musick ·
opinion

2025's Top Tech Trends That Adult Retailers Should Know About

I just got back from the National Retail Federation’s Annual Convention & Expo, also known as “Retail’s Big Show,” where I walked the floor, sat in on key panels, talked with industry experts and influencers, and did my best to sift through the b.s. so I could report back to you all on the things you need to care about.

Sean Quinn ·
opinion

Protecting Content Ownership Rights When Using AI

In today’s digital age, content producers have more tools at their disposal than ever before. Among these tools, artificial intelligence (AI) content generation has emerged as a game changer, enabling creators to produce high-quality content quickly and efficiently.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Understanding the Importance of Graphic Design in Sexual Wellness Social Media Marketing

In the world of social media, graphic design is more than just making things look visually appealing — it’s a vital tool in shaping and maintaining a brand’s identity. Your social media is your storefront, so aesthetics mean everything.

Hannah McManus ·
opinion

How Adult Retail Is Shaping Sexual Health One Customer at a Time

Remember back in health class, when they taught us about boundaries, consent and how many nerve endings are in the clitoris? Of course you don’t, because it didn’t happen. In fact, sex education is still severely lacking in much of the U.S.

Kimberly Scott Faubel ·
trends

Meet the Up-and-Coming Pleasure Brands of 2025

Over the past year, the pleasure industry has witnessed the emergence of new brands across various adult retail categories — brands that are now entering 2025 with ambitious goals for success and growth in their sophomore year.

Ariana Rodriguez ·
profile

WIA Profile: Nefertiti Mitchell

Local retailers are the backbone of the pleasure industry. Driven by passionate business owners who are deeply dedicated to sexual wellness, brick-and-mortar stores serve as safe spaces that uplift and delight customers — while greasing the wheels of commerce for manufacturers and distributors.

Women In Adult ·
profile

Industry Vet Mike Savage Discusses Comeback, Goals With Full Circle Distribution

"We never know where life’s going to take us,” says Mike Savage. He should know. The pleasure biz veteran, who describes himself as “a poor Irish kid from Philly,” first made his name in the adult retail biz over the course of a nearly 40-year career.

Ariana Rodriguez ·
profile

Sensually Yours Founder Shellee Rose on Boosting Sex Positivity in Hawaii

Honolulu pleasure store Sensually Yours has served Hawaii for 40 years, establishing itself as a top destination for adult products. Founder and President Shellee Rose says her most important strategy for achieving four decades of success has been prioritizing customers.

Quinton Bellamie ·
Show More