opinion

The End of the Beginning?

When I saw attorney and Free Speech Coalition Board Chair Jeffrey Douglas recently at a Los Angeles trade event, where he was speaking on a panel after having just returned from Phoenix and the just-concluded JM/5 Star obscenity case, he was like a new man.

With an irrepressible Cheshire cat grin and eyes glinting with glee, he leaned into the microphone and recounted in withering detail (and palpable satisfaction) how miserably deficient the government's case had been, and how important the victory had been for the plaintiffs and the industry.

But like all experienced lawyers, Douglas knows that benevolent tidings for an outlaw industry can never be counted on to last very long. Indeed, when we win big victories, they seem to inspire dreadful overreaction by an assortment of enemies at all levels. The result is that we seem to be the boy forever sticking an insufficient number of fingers into the holes of the dyke.

The problem with this perception of uncertain advancement is that it may be less accurate than it appears. The big picture reality, which is so hard to glean when dealing with a battlefield so vast and disjointed, could be that the tide truly is starting to turn regarding the ability of adult companies to stay in business without having to always keep an eye over their shoulder for the next insufferable zoning law, dancer/performer regulation, township ordinance, obscenity charge, 2257 inspection, etc.

The justification for optimism is not just the JM victory, but also the ruling in October by the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that overturned the 2257 record-keeping regulations in Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Tennessee. That ruling came in the Connection Distributing vs. Gonzales case, brilliantly litigated by Connection attorney J. Michael Murray, which has been underway since 1995 and has taken a public back seat to the more widely-publicized FSC vs. Gonzales lawsuit brought in 2005 in U.S. District Court in Colorado.

In the Connection case, the government had argued that 2257 was aimed only at conduct and not speech, but Judge Cornelia G. Kennedy said in the opinion, "This argument is unpersuasive. While the government is indeed aiming at conduct, child abuse, it is regulating protected speech, sexually explicit images of adults, to get at that conduct."

We do not know at this time if this ruling will be appealed by the Justice Department, first to the full panel of the 6th Circuit and then if affirmed to the U.S. Supreme Court, but hopes are high that the sound reasoning of the court will prevail across the board. If so, it will be a stunning victory for the industry and the federal courts, which will have upheld an essential legal right that is also one of the cornerstones of democratic jurisprudence.

The Justice Department has only just had its new attorney general confirmed by the U.S. Senate, so we have no clue whether it will continue to play hardball with the industry. Neither do we know if the final year leading up to the presidential election will bring an avalanche of anti-porn accusations and demands for action from both Democratic and Republican candidates, but I would not doubt it.

What I do know is that these victories could not have come at a better time. We needed them because we needed to see that we are not alone and have "friends" in high places. The question now is whether we can we get our act together to build on those victories?

Related:  

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

Best Practices for Payment Gateway Security

Securing digital payment transactions is critical for all businesses, but especially those in high-risk industries. Payment gateways are a core component of the digital payment ecosystem, and therefore must follow best practices to keep customer data safe.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

Ready for New Visa Acquirer Changes?

Next spring, Visa will roll out the U.S. version of its new Visa Acquirer Monitoring Program (VAMP), which goes into effect April 1, 2025. This follows Visa Europe, which rolled out VAMP back in June. VAMP charts a new path for acquirers to manage fraud and chargeback ratios.

Cathy Beardsley ·
profile

WIA Profile: Siren Obscura

Siren Obscura grew up in Arizona, surrounded by rugged beauty and desert landscapes that she describes as having a quiet power to them. That environment strongly shaped her appreciation for contrasts and natural light, which plays a significant role in her work today.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

How to Thwart Holiday Fraudsters With Finesse

The holiday season is a prime time for shopping. Unfortunately, it’s also peak season for credit card fraud. With increased transactions both online and in-store, fraudsters have more opportunities to exploit vulnerabilities — and they are getting better at it every day.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

How to Halt Hackers as Fraud Attacks Rise

For hackers, it’s often a game of trial and error. Bad actors will perform enumeration and account testing, repeating the same test on a system to look for vulnerabilities — and if you are not equipped with the proper tools, your merchant account could be the next target.

Cathy Beardsley ·
profile

VerifyMy Seeks to Provide Frictionless Online Safety, Compliance Solutions

Before founding VerifyMy, Ryan Shaw was simply looking for an age verification solution for his previous business. The ones he found, however, were too expensive, too difficult to integrate with, or failed to take into account the needs of either the businesses implementing them or the end users who would be required to interact with them.

Alejandro Freixes ·
opinion

How Adult Website Operators Can Cash in on the 'Interchange' Class Action

The Payment Card Interchange Fee Settlement resulted from a landmark antitrust lawsuit involving Visa, Mastercard and several major banks. The case centered around the interchange fees charged to merchants for processing credit and debit card transactions. These fees are set by card networks and are paid by merchants to the banks that issue the cards.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

It's Time to Rock the Vote and Make Your Voice Heard

When I worked to defeat California’s Proposition 60 in 2016, our opposition campaign was outspent nearly 10 to 1. Nevertheless, our community came together and garnered enough support and awareness to defeat that harmful, misguided piece of proposed legislation — by more than a million votes.

Siouxsie Q ·
opinion

Staying Compliant to Avoid the Takedown Shakedown

Dealing with complaints is an everyday part of doing business — and a crucial one, since not dealing with them properly can haunt your business in multiple ways. Card brand regulations require every merchant doing business online to have in place a complaint process for reporting content that may be illegal or that violates the card brand rules.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Girlsway Celebrates a Decade of Acclaimed Sapphic Erotica

When Girlsway launched back in 2014, Bree Mills had a plan. As head of production for Gamma Entertainment, she set out to up the stakes of all-girl content with the new imprint — and to continually, proactively reinvent the brand and its offerings along the way.

Alejandro Freixes ·
Show More