Porn Copyright Trolling Law Firm Loses $230K Sanction Appeal

Porn Copyright Trolling Law Firm Loses $230K Sanction Appeal

PASADENA, Calif. — The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Friday upheld more than $230,000 in sanctions against the attorneys who for years operated the porn copyright trolling law firm Prenda Law.

Attorneys John Steele and Paul Hansmeier, as well as the deceased lawyer Paul Duffy, created a “scheme,” the 9th Circuit said in its 12-page decision, that started to unravel when they faced U.S. District Judge Otis Wright, who levied sanctions against them in 2013.

Friday’s decision defends Wright's sanction and didn’t move forward the argument that the Prenda Law attorneys' due process rights were violated. Prenda Law’s appellate attorney last year sought for the sanctions to be tossed or, alternatively, a separate hearing on the sanctions to be held.

The 9th Circuit, in its description of Prenda Law’s method of operation, said the attorneys filed mass lawsuits against thousands of defendants, accusing them of illegally downloading porn movies.

“The Prenda principals, through their law firm, Prenda Law Inc., set up a number of shell companies, including Ingenuity 13 LLC and AF Holdings LLC, which purchased copyrights to pornographic movies,” the 9th Circuit wrote. “When one of those movies was illegally downloaded, the shell company (via Prenda Law or a local attorney hired by Prenda Law) filed a complaint against John Doe in federal or state court for copyright infringement and used early discovery mechanisms to determine the identities of the persons it alleged illegally downloaded the film.”

The court said that the shell company would then mail the typical John Does a letter threatening to sue unless the individual paid roughly $4,000 to “settle” the case.

“Out of embarrassment and for economic reasons, many John Does settled, regardless of whether they, or another family member, friend, or guest, infringed the copyright. When the John Does settled, Prenda Law would voluntarily dismiss the case; Prenda Law never litigated a single copyright infringement case through to a merits judgment.

By misusing the subpoena power of the court, the court said, Prenda Law made millions of dollars from suing hundreds to thousands of John Does across the country.

Things started to unravel for the law firm after courts nationwide started catching on to the its real business of copyright trolling, the court said.

"Prenda principals were found contradicting themselves, evading questioning and possibly committing identity theft and fraud on the courts," the 9th Circuit said.

Before Steele, Hansmeier and Duffy’s hearing was allowed to proceed with the appeal of sanctions, Wright ordered that the firm pay two bonds totaling more than $230,000.

The first bond consisted of the full $81,000 sanction, multiplied by 125 percent to account for interest. The second bond was $135,000, the estimated legal costs of John Doe’s defense attorney, Morgan Pietz.

The 9th Circuit on Friday held that the three Prenda lawyers, despite their arguments to the contrary, received due process for civil sanctions requiring notice, an opportunity to be heard and a finding of bad faith.

“[I]t was not an abuse of discretion for Judge Wright to find that the Prenda principals were indeed the leaders and decision-makers behind Prenda Law’s national trolling scheme,” the 9th Circuit said.

Further, "They have lied to other courts about their ability to pay sanctions. They also failed to pay their own attorney’s fees in this case."

A 2015 video of oral arguments in the appeal before the 9th Circuit can be accessed here.

View Friday's ruling

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

FSC Publishes Analysis of Federal Trade Commission Event Promoting AV

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has published an analysis of a Federal Trade Commission (FTC) event held this week that promoted age verification among other forms of speech regulation.

GirlsDoPorn Owner Michael Pratt Pleads Guilty to Sex Trafficking

Michael Pratt, former owner of the rogue website GirlsDoPorn, pleaded guilty in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California on Thursday to sex trafficking and conspiracy to commit sex trafficking charges, according to a report by City News Service.

Master Nico Relaunches Site Through YourPaysitePartner

Master Nico has relaunched his official website through YourPaysitePartner (YPP).

Federal Judge Grants Partial Halt of Florida AV Law

The United States District Court for the Northern District of Florida, Tallahassee Division, has granted a preliminary injunction against HB 3, the state's age verification law, as a lawsuit filed by two online trade associations challenging the law makes its way through the courts.

Aylo Releases Statement on Suspending Access to Pornhub in France

Technology and media company Aylo, which operates adult sites including Pornhub, YouPorn, and Redtube, has released a public statement regarding its decision to block access to its sites in France.

Pineapple Support to Host Wellness Sessions at Bucharest Summit

Pineapple Support is hosting free group and one-on-one therapy sessions at Bucharest Summit, June 3-5.

Pornhub Blocks Access in France in Response to SREN Law

Pornhub parent company Aylo has opted to block access to its sites in France rather than comply with age verification requirements under the country’s Security and Regulation of the Digital Space (SREN) law.

ASACP Highlights Study on Parental Controls

The Association of Sites Advocating Child Protection (ASACP) is highlighting the results of a study on the underutilization of parental controls.

Sydney Screams Launches New Site Through Grooby's Blue.xxx

Sydney Screams has launched her new membership site, SydneyScreams.xxx, through Grooby's website management company Blue.xxx.

Mistress Mystii Is LoyalFans' 'Featured Creator' for June

LoyalFans has named Mistress Mystii as its Featured Creator for June.

Show More