Martha's Vineyard Case: Judge Nixes Questions About Anti-Porn Prejudice

Martha's Vineyard Case: Judge Nixes Questions About Anti-Porn Prejudice

BOSTON — A Massachusetts judge presiding over the trial involving a Martha's Vineyard landlord who is suing Mile High Media and several associates for a 2014 incident involving artwork in her rental property — which she claimed could be seen onscreen in several adult videos — rejected the defense’s proposed questions for potential jurors about prejudicial views and attitudes about pornography.

During a hearing yesterday, U.S. District Judge Patti B. Saris told counsel that she “will not be asking people whether they watch pornography and ask them to say that under oath.”

According to legal news site Law360, the proposed questions “also would have asked jurors whether they have negative views of gay or transsexual pornography, or whether they think pornography is illegal, a danger to the community or ‘generally leads to the degradation of the morals of the individuals involved in the industry and/or society as a whole.’”

Additional jury selection questions proposed by the defense also reportedly included, "By a show of hands, how many of you have ever watched a pornographic movie?" and "By a show of hands, have any of you or close family members ever been involved in the making of pornography?"

Gary Jay Kaufman of the Kaufman Law Group, which represents Mile High, argued that “clearly in this case there are sensitive issues, gay rights issues, gay versus straight pornography, pornography in general — these are not things I love talking about.”

Law360 reports that Judge Saris cut him off at that point and, raising her voice, declared, "I can't ask people if they are gay or ask them their views on transsexual sex. You can't ask that of people!"

Judge Saris instead offered to alert jurors "that the case would involve issues of pornography that will involve gay or transsexual sex," followed by, "Is there anyone here who would not be able to be fair and impartial?"

Kaufman, Law360 continued, “likened the questions to asking prospective jurors in a sexual assault case whether they or anyone they know had been a victim of a similar assault, but the judge was not persuaded.”

Judge Saris replied that she “can't put people under oath and say, ‘Do you watch porn?’”

For XBIZ’s ongoing coverage of the "Martha’s Vineyard Background Art" case, click here.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Phoenix Marie Stars in Latest From Blacked

Phoenix Marie stars with Isiah Maxwell, Hollywood Cash, and Chocolate Rod in a new airtight scene from Vixen Media Group studio imprint Blacked.

Eris Jolie Stars in Latest Release From GroobyVR

Eris Jolie stars in the latest POV release from GroobyVR.

Amirah Adara, Leya Desantis & Annalisa Atomic Blonde Star in 'Wicked Games' From MixedX

Amirah Adara, Leya Desantis and Annalisa Atomic Blonde star in the latest MixedX scene, “Wicked Games.”

Brazzers Debuts Limited Series 'MILF Spa'

Brazzers has released the first installment of its new limited series, "MILF Spa."

Casey Calvert, Victoria Voxxx Star in Latest 'Lez Be Bad'

Casey Calvert stars with Victoria Voxxx in "A Gift That Keeps on Giving," the latest episode of Adult Time series "Lez Be Bad."

BiPhoria Releases Jim Powers' 'Bi Hitchhikers 2'

Jim Powers directs the second installment of the BiPhoria series “Bi Hitchhikers.”

Ariel Demure Toplines 'TS Cheaters 6' From TransSensual

Ariel Demure headlines the sixth volume of “TS Cheaters,” from Mile High Media studio imprint TransSensual.

Kalani Luana Stars in Latest From Hookup Hotshot

Kalani Luana stars with Nade Nasty in the latest release from Hookup Hotshot (HUHS).

Lilyadick Makes Her TransAngels Debut

Canadian star Lilyadick has made her debut for TransAngels alongside Parker Savage in the video game-themed scene “Playing With The NPC Babe.”

Kazumi Stars in Latest From Tushy

Kazumi stars with Milan Ponjevic, Jax Slayher and Dan Damage in a new airtight scene from Vixen Media Group (VMG) studio imprint Tushy.

Show More