opinion

Infringing on Someone’s Domain?

I spoke with Dan Pepper of the Pepper Law Group not too long ago, about copyright and trademark.  There is a lot of copyright discussion these days; piracy and lawsuits, but our conversation drifted to a discussion of domain names, and when is the use of someone else's trademark in a domain name considered infringement?  So many domain names can contain terms trademarked by another party, but does that mean the URL owner is actually infringing on the trademark owner?  Dan told me there are legitimate and non-legitimate scenarios, and you need to know that some are perfectly permissible.  I’ve seen some other articles on this subject on the ‘net, and we will likely see more as people and businesses move to protect their hard-earned branding and marketing efforts.

Dan said that for the use of a particular domain to constitute cyber squatting, the owner of the trademark must generally prove they hold legitimate trademark rights in that name, that the infringement of the domain names involved allegedly present as “identical or confusingly similar” to the trademarked name, that there is no legitimate right of the allegedly infringing URL owner to use the name, and the one that’s hard to prove - that the URL in question was registered and used in bad faith. 

He further explained that there are subtle differences between cases where commercial enterprise trademarks are concerned in relation to other types of trademarks.  Commercial enterprises very often have names very similar to each other and, consequently, multiple parties may all retain genuine claims to the domain and, in fact, there are usually as many different uses of the name as there are parties claiming it.  It’s a complicated scenario, and he compared it to the use of a celebrity name or trademark, where it is much more obviously a unique personal celebrity brand, and almost always more difficult for the domain URL owner to prove that they have a legitimate right to use the celebrity's trademark – if it happens to really be their own name, that can become a factor.

Dan said commercial enterprises have the ability to access a number of defenses that are not available to those defending a celebrity domain name trademark action.  He proposed that commercial defendants could argue they operate a business with a different nature and purpose from that of the trademark holder.  This can be effectively bolstered where the business is not in competition with that of the trademark holder.  If the services of the domains in question complement the trademark holder’s business, this can actually help their cause in retaining use of the domain.

He further cautioned that if you do choose to use a domain name that is in conflict with any of the millions of commercial names in existence online, you always run the risk of losing it.  As we expend marketing budgets and sweat equity marketing our websites and building online brands – the prospect of being forced to relinquish your domain after establishment of your online presence will likely destroy your enterprise.  Finding a new momentum or your past efforts will likely be impossible.  It appears the message here is - don’t take shortcuts and choose your domain name carefully...   

He offers the following trademark rules as a guide, and said that every attorney will advise you to seriously consider these:

  • Names that identify the source of products or services in the marketplace are trademarks.
  • Trademarks that are clever, memorable or suggestive are protected under federal and state law.
  • Trademarks that are descriptive and have achieved distinction through sales and advertising can be protected under federal and state law.
  • One trademark legally conflicts with another when the use of both trademarks is likely to confuse customers about the products or services, or their source.
  • In the case of a legal conflict with a later user, the first commercial user of a trademark owns it.
  • If a legal conflict is found to exist, the later user will likely have to cease using the mark - and may even have to pay the first trademark owner damages.

Dan continued, telling me if you can answer ‘no’ to all of these questions, you can feel reasonably confident that you can use a URL without fearing the creation of a legal conflict.  If you answer yes to any of them, you will always be facing a possible future legal challenge.  If you are unsure, run your concerns by a trademark attorney for an expert opinion.  You can anticipate that the attorney will be more conservative than is actually necessary [surprise!], but you can still benefit from having an experienced review of your choices, and have a better understanding of what your choices and future expectations may be.

Daniel A. Pepper, Esq. is the managing member of the New Jersey-based law firm Pepper Law Group, LLC, and has been practicing law since 1994.  His practice areas include First Amendment rights, obscenity law, Internet Law, software and technology licensing, electronic commerce, and intellectual property protection.  Mr. Pepper regularly advises his clients on cross-border technology transfers, affiliate, distribution, and marketing, technology deployment, e-commerce and Internet strategies, including compliance with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, and data security and privacy management.  The Pepper Law Group website can be found at:  www.informationlaw.com, and the firm can be reached at 908.698.0330.

Write JoeD with any questions.

Stats Source:  https://www.entersekt.com/russian-roulette.php

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

How to Master Team Dynamics for Startup Success

Having the right team in place is everything. That’s true in most aspects of business, but doubly so when it comes to getting a startup off the ground and thriving. The right — or wrong — people can mean the difference between a successful venture and a failed dream.

Juicy Jay ·
opinion

The Power of Authenticity in Selling Pleasure Products

I’ve been working in the pleasure industry for more than two decades. For a significant chunk of that time, I thought that to be successful in sales, I had to fit a mold. I assumed that selling meant following a formula: say the right things, use the right voice and present myself in a way that was guaranteed to convert.

Kimberly Scott Faubel ·
opinion

Eight Steps to Fast-Track AI Site Approval for Processing

Artificial intelligence is a hot topic these days. AI technology is speeding up the way we do business across all industries and offers numerous benefits, from automating processes to increasing efficiency and scalability.

Cathy Beardsley ·
profile

Dennis DeSantis on Building a Blockbuster Career in Adult Retail

The adult industry and the mainstream Hollywood scene often intersect, and few executives are more familiar with that crossover than Dennis DeSantis.

Ariana Rodriguez ·
opinion

How to Secure High-Risk Transactions With Network Tokenization

Ensuring the security of data as it moves through digital channels is the foundation of safe transactions, and crucial for your success. If your business can’t secure transactions, you’re exposed to myriad processing traumas.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

'Pleasure Professionals Place' Facebook Group Marks 5 Years of Fostering Connections

Where can you find the pleasure industry’s most tantalizing, trending and relevant conversational banter? For once, we’re not talking about a trade show after-party!

Colleen Godin ·
opinion

How Cannabis Culture Is Reshaping Sexual Wellness, Pleasure

April is a month of celebration: Lovers Day, Earth Day… and 4/20. Once a subculture symbol, “420” has evolved into a movement that bridges cannabis advocacy, wellness and an increasingly vital discussion around sexual health and pleasure.

Ian Kulp ·
profile

Lea Lexis On Challenging the Porn Status Quo

Lea Lexis doesn’t just aim to make movies — she wants to craft experiences. Bending the rules of what’s possible in moviemaking with the precision of a true auteur, the performer-turned-Brazzers producer has helped shape some of the industry’s most striking and boundary-pushing productions.

Jackie Backman ·
profile

WIA Profile: Holly Corbella

Even during last year’s retail slump, the adult home party business continued to rock and roll — at least in New Jersey. Just ask Holly Corbella. Based in the Garden State, Corbella is the founder, CEO and lead party planner for Parties by Bellas, an intimate, in-home sex toy event company focusing on creating budget-friendly home parties for women on the East Coast.

Women In Adult ·
profile

Thor Johnson: Hard Hat Hustle to Fav Male Creator

Thor Johnson never expected to become one of the biggest names in adult entertainment — he just hit “upload” and let fate take the wheel. What started as a private video for his girlfriend turned into an unexpected career after it went viral, leading to his dismissal from a grueling oil field job and a crash course in the power of online adult content.

Jackie Backman ·
Show More