profile

Legal Angels: 2

In part one, we began our look at the impact L.A.-based attorneys have had on 1st Amendment law. We'll continue our look in this conclusion:

Landmark Miller
Another L.A.-based attorney, Burton Marks, played a key role in a subsequent Supreme Court ruling: 1973's landmark decision in Miller vs. California, which established a new test for obscenity. Parts of the Roth test were upheld in the Miller test, but while the Roth test described obscenity as being "utterly without redeeming social importance," the Miller test said that obscenity lacks "serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value," so called the "SLAPS test." In 1973, some 1st Amendment attorneys regarded the SLAPS part of the Miller test as a setback for adult entertainment; nonetheless, it was during the 1970s that the adult film explosion took erotica to a new level of sexual explicitness, and defending the content of sexually explicit films (including oral sex) kept Los Angeles 1st Amendment lawyers busy.

Laws prohibiting oral sex were common at the time, and L.A.-based attorneys argued that such laws were unconstitutional. Weston challenged the constitutionality of California's oral sex prohibition, which the California State Supreme Court repealed in 1976. And 12 years later, in 1988, adult film companies in California enjoyed another major victory when the California State Supreme Court made its historic decision in Freeman vs. California.

When Los Angeles County prosecutors alleged that paying people to have sex on camera was pandering, and adult filmmaker Hal Freeman was convicted of five pandering counts, his Los Angeles attorneys, Stuart Goldfarb and Dennis A. Fischer, appealed. The case went to the California State Supreme Court, which ruled that paying adult actors to have sex on camera was not a form of pimping or pandering.

"As far as Los Angeles is concerned," Gelbard said, "it's hard to talk about adult entertainment without mentioning the Freeman decision, which basically made it legal to make adult films here, and that sort of opened the flood gates."

Piccionelli agreed. "With the Freeman decision, California became the first state in the country to actually create a legal sanctuary for the commercial creation of adult films," he said. "The Freeman decision is one of the reasons why the adult entertainment industry is located here."

Weston, on the other hand, has a long history of challenging zoning ordinances he considered discriminatory against adult bookstores, beginning with the case Young vs. American Mini Theaters in 1976, and has also been proactive in challenging RICO statutes that have been aggressively used against adult businesses. Also of great importance was Weston's work in the Traci Lords case. In 1986, it was discovered that actress Lords had lied about her age and was a minor when she posed nude for Penthouse and made roughly 200 erotic films.

"The adult industry could have been wiped out," Weston said. "Theoretically, everyone who had hired Traci Lords was subject to prosecution."

Adult Industry Saved
But the courts ruled that there could not be strict liability, and all of the people who had created or distributed Lords' material not knowing that she was underage when it was made breathed a huge sigh of relief.

"That decision saved the adult industry," Weston added.

Although adult entertainment has come a long way since Fleishman's groundbreaking work in the 1950s and 1960s (Fleishman generally defended more softcore erotica, and his successors more hardcore material), erotic expression still has its share of opponents. In the 2000s, L.A.-based 1st Amendment attorneys have been busy dealing with both federal obscenity prosecutions and 2257 age-verification laws that Gelbard describes as "Draconian."

Adult entertainment, however, is not the only target of social conservatives, who, as Piccionelli explained, also go after mainstream entertainment, be it Hollywood films, hip-hop or video games. Piccionelli stressed that Los Angeles will maintain a vibrant community of 1st Amendment lawyers not only because of adult entertainment but also because of all the mainstream entertainment that is created in Southern California.

"Los Angeles has a long history of pushing envelopes," Piccionelli said. "There are very few places in the country where you can say that cultural phenomenon gets going with regularity, and Los Angeles is one of those places. Wherever you have cultural advancement and expression of that advancement, you're going to run up against folks who are not happy about those changes and who will try to restrain them. Because of the location of the adult entertainment industry and the non-adult entertainment industry in Southern California, Los Angeles will continue to be an important place for 1st Amendment attorneys."

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

How to Thwart Holiday Fraudsters With Finesse

The holiday season is a prime time for shopping. Unfortunately, it’s also peak season for credit card fraud. With increased transactions both online and in-store, fraudsters have more opportunities to exploit vulnerabilities — and they are getting better at it every day.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

How to Halt Hackers as Fraud Attacks Rise

For hackers, it’s often a game of trial and error. Bad actors will perform enumeration and account testing, repeating the same test on a system to look for vulnerabilities — and if you are not equipped with the proper tools, your merchant account could be the next target.

Cathy Beardsley ·
profile

VerifyMy Seeks to Provide Frictionless Online Safety, Compliance Solutions

Before founding VerifyMy, Ryan Shaw was simply looking for an age verification solution for his previous business. The ones he found, however, were too expensive, too difficult to integrate with, or failed to take into account the needs of either the businesses implementing them or the end users who would be required to interact with them.

Alejandro Freixes ·
opinion

How Adult Website Operators Can Cash in on the 'Interchange' Class Action

The Payment Card Interchange Fee Settlement resulted from a landmark antitrust lawsuit involving Visa, Mastercard and several major banks. The case centered around the interchange fees charged to merchants for processing credit and debit card transactions. These fees are set by card networks and are paid by merchants to the banks that issue the cards.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

It's Time to Rock the Vote and Make Your Voice Heard

When I worked to defeat California’s Proposition 60 in 2016, our opposition campaign was outspent nearly 10 to 1. Nevertheless, our community came together and garnered enough support and awareness to defeat that harmful, misguided piece of proposed legislation — by more than a million votes.

Siouxsie Q ·
opinion

Staying Compliant to Avoid the Takedown Shakedown

Dealing with complaints is an everyday part of doing business — and a crucial one, since not dealing with them properly can haunt your business in multiple ways. Card brand regulations require every merchant doing business online to have in place a complaint process for reporting content that may be illegal or that violates the card brand rules.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Girlsway Celebrates a Decade of Acclaimed Sapphic Erotica

When Girlsway launched back in 2014, Bree Mills had a plan. As head of production for Gamma Entertainment, she set out to up the stakes of all-girl content with the new imprint — and to continually, proactively reinvent the brand and its offerings along the way.

Alejandro Freixes ·
profile

WIA Profile: Patricia Ucros

Born in Bogota, Colombia, Ucros graduated from college with a degree in education. She spent three years teaching third grade, which she enjoyed a lot, before heeding her father’s advice and moving to South Florida.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

Creating Payment Redundancies to Maximize Payout Uptime

During the global CrowdStrike outage that took place toward the end of July, a flawed software update brought air travel and electronic commerce to a grinding halt worldwide. This dramatically underscores the importance of having a backup plan in place for critical infrastructure.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

The Need for Minimal Friction in Age Verification Technology

In the adult sector, robust age assurance, comprised of age verification and age estimation methods, is critical to ensuring legal compliance with ever-evolving regulations, safeguarding minors from inappropriate content and protecting the privacy of adults wishing to view adult content.

Gavin Worrall ·
Show More